SPS color problems - Page 2

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1guyDude 

ya wish i knew that before the fact lol!!!!

Is it better to just throw em in the DT....or do i need to add revive to the RO before dipping em next time???

Api liquid tests....reef and master.

Honestly, grab a bottle of Melafix the next time you can, it's not expensive (less than $12 usually). I've found it to be much, much less stressful on the corals. I mix it with tank water and dip them, then add them to the main tank.

API kits, I'm not a fan if you're going to do SPS. Start switching to Salifert for your Alk and Calcium and SeaChem for nitrate.

melafix to dip sps???? HMMMMM never heard of it

I like API for basics..ammonia nitrite and nitrates   NOT PH...LOL...could never read it

I use salifert for calcium, alk and mag...and now PH

I'm spoiled, I have a pH probe, but I'm thinking about getting the Salifert as a back up tester.

I was turned onto dipping SPS with Melafix by a few members from a very prominent and high end store in Manhattan. Then I heard about it again from local reefers, etc. Then I heard the owner the aquarium out near me talking about it. After trying it, I have to say, I've had less loss and much less stress.

There's a lot of threads on other boards about dipping melafix, but there was a mention of it here:

http://forums.saltwaterfish.com/forum/thread/346468/melafix-dip

Personally, I've seen it kill red bugs, so I'm sold because using Interceptor is a hassle for me.

Just because an SPS shows great/good polyp extension doesn't mean the coral is thriving......

Quote:

Originally Posted by acrylic51 

Just because an SPS shows great/good polyp extension doesn't mean the coral is thriving......

I only speak from meager experience. Polyp extension *may* only indicate hunger, perhaps the final gasp. I've read many studies/reports/anecdotes that indicate the quest for large polyp extension is really a quest to starve their SPS. FWIW only

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1guyDude 

agreed....only part of it! Good color and tissue covering the skeleton too....

grr the sps's are just so unforgiving and touchy

That don't mean squat either. Things die.

Anecdotal only, I bought a 5 piece ORA frag pack a few months ago. This was after already having several SPS from frag swaps. The Red Planet is a monster, as well as the Purple/Green, the Rose Millie and the Pearlberry. BUT, the Yellow Fuzzie never did anything...no polyps, nothing except slowly die. It's skeleton is now on the kitchen window sill.

I have a stunner acro that has encrusted but not grown out, It looks glorious, but no outward growth. I have a green slimer that has encrusted wonderfully but has not grown outwards yet, after 5 months.

Corals do what corals do.

I have pieces that do whatever they want regardless of what I do. Then there are other pieces that do whatever they want regardless of what I do.

They should have polyp extension......If your not getting growth that's a different issue, that could be attributed to water parameters......

Quote:

Originally Posted by acrylic51 

They should have polyp extension......If your not getting growth that's a different issue, that could be attributed to water parameters......

There is no way on this earth I will ever argue with you.

In my tank, there have a variety of corals that have done well.....or not. The variables have been many; where they came from, how long in limbo, etc.

Coral in my tank do what they say, not what I say. (so far, we have agreed to a high percentage)

.

Slice I wasn't debating what you posted.....I was more responding to 1Guy saying he has good color and tissue covering the skeleton.....I was more curious if he's seeing any growth or are they just sustaining themselves???  If there isn't any growth could be a parameter issue....Doesn't necessarily have to be something major.