10k or 20k?

blazehok68

Active Member
well its time to order lights for my 120 gal. i found a dual 250 watt mh retro for like 275 bucks shipped! the question is 10k or 20k bulbs. i am gonna supplement actinics in the canopy. im gonna take apart my 4x65 pc fixture and make all of them actinic in the canopy. so which bulbs should i use?
20k bulbs are bluer and 10k are yellower arent they? my only choice is 10 or 20 k bulbs. i would choose 14k if they were available.
any info is appreciated
joe
 

schneidts

Active Member
Originally Posted by BLAZEHOK68
well its time to order lights for my 120 gal. i found a dual 250 watt mh retro for like 275 bucks shipped! the question is 10k or 20k bulbs. i am gonna supplement actinics in the canopy. im gonna take apart my 4x65 pc fixture and make all of them actinic in the canopy. so which bulbs should i use?
20k bulbs are bluer and 10k are yellower arent they? my only choice is 10 or 20 k bulbs. i would choose 14k if they were available.
any info is appreciated
joe
I would suggest 10k if you're going to have four actinics. 20k themselves are pretty blue...but it's personal preference.
 

emperor11

Active Member
I personally prefer 20k's. They really aren't all that blue, they're basically white with a TINY amount of a blue tint. 10k's are WAY too yellow, even with actinics, IMO.
 

saltfan

Active Member
Originally Posted by Emperor11
I personally prefer 20k's. They really aren't all that blue, they're basically white with a TINY amount of a blue tint. 10k's are WAY too yellow, even with actinics, IMO.
I second that, I use the 20k myself.
 

emperor11

Active Member
Originally Posted by schneidts
with actinic supplementation?
Personally, I think tanks looks FANTASTIC with 20k's and actinics.
 

buzzword

Member
Why can't you get 14K? I have dual 250w mogul base and run 14K's with 4x65w PC actinics and love the color.
 

saltfan

Active Member
Originally Posted by schneidts
with actinic supplementation?
Oh yes, srry left that out. They are not by themselves.
 

blazehok68

Active Member
Originally Posted by Buzzword
Why can't you get 14K? I have dual 250w mogul base and run 14K's with 4x65w PC actinics and love the color.
THE 14KS ARE NOT OFFERED IN THE AUCTION
 

mrdc

Active Member
I have 10k with 4 65w actincs. I plan to go with the 14 or 20k when I replace the bulbs.
 

oceana

Active Member
Originally Posted by Emperor11
Heck, I wish they had 35k's!

really they do. in most cases the kelvin rating means jack crap. most 20 k bulbs are more like 40 or 50k.
I use Radium bulbs which some call 20k but really they are just blue. the company odes not get into the k rating becaseu its subjective to many factors. IE: take three"20k" bulbs and run them on the same ballast and conditions and you will find they are all different.
try to think of your lighting like this
6500k
very yellow, great coral growth. coral color very bland. algea growth very good under this light. must have actinics to provided the corals with proper spectrums
10000K bulbs.
still rather yellow. great coral growth. coral color Available in every brand and type (almost). all the right spectrums. needs actinic to be eye pleasing IMO.
14-15K
very nice white color. still has great coral growth.coral color looks good, all the right spectrums. does not need actinic however most people do in order to have the night lighting and even better color.
20000K
very bright ice blue whitish color., less coral growth, coral color is top notch. less algea growth. no need for actinic however should be used to have a night effect for when the halides turn off. less par so you get less penatration but for the most part its not enough to worry about.
I think the Radium brand bulb is a super nice choice. only down side IMO is they are a bit pricey. they need to be run on pulse start magnetic ballast, perferably german made ballast for best results. search my name , just about every pic you find is under radium bulbs. you will find that almost noone will argue the fact that NOTHING makes a coral look better then a radium bulb does.
well GL to ya
 

blazehok68

Active Member
ok, so according to oceana, the 10 k bulbs seem like the best for coral growth?? does this sound right? mainly i want whats best for the corals. i am going to supplement actinics, so the color will look better. its just so confusing. i just want this tank to be awesome.
 

dejaco

Member
Hey can only speak for myself. But in my 210 g I run two 250 watt 10,000 K MH's
and then two 160 watt VHo actinic blue's. Between them all the color effects are great.
The coralline, corals, inverts, and fish all seem to thrive. And above all else the MH's
give the ripple sparkling effect of sunlight on ocean surface. I am still new at this, but
from snorkling I think the tank looks close to real life 3' - 10' below. JMO
 
Top