29 gal suggestions please

6mmmedic

Member
So I started this thread in the reef section yesterday, but have gotten no replies. Maybe some you here can help me!!
I am looking at taking a 29 gallon setup with a Marineland Eclipse system and making it a small reef. The lights in that system are T8's so I need some opinions on what to put in it. Can I do some low light corals or would I be better of with just fish? And how about a skimmer? With frequent water changes, do I need a skimmer? Some of you throw me some input!! Just looking for suggestions right now..... Thanks!
 

jubbin2001

Member
My first tank was a 29g actually. I have since moved on and got addicted and have a 125g reef, the 29g is my sea horse tank (which is moving to a 24g nano cube), I have a 40g that is going to be another tank (not sure what atm) and I am currently working on building a multiple tank octopus lair
.
I suppose I should attempt to answer your question
.
1. The smaller the aquarium the more you have to watch your water. The nice thing about bigger tanks is they tend to dillute out issues giving you more time to catch and repair them, so keep in mind that you should watch a little more closely with a smaller tank.
2. Filters - My first tank was a Skilter filter, a Marineland H.O.T. Magnum Pro, 30lbs of live sand, and about 25lbs of live rock (the more the better). I did water changes once a month, checked my parameters every other day, and everything really worked well. Though I don't always recommend going down this route - it can be done, depends on how much you want/can spend.
3. Lighting - This is where it gets expensive
. Depending on what kind of coral/critters you want to keep will determine what lighting you have. I am sorry to say, but your T8 will really not be good enough for anything. Eventually any coral you put under it will die. You can do Metal Halide, T5, or Power Compacts. On my 29g I had a Coralife 30" dual bulb PC and kept a great many different LPS, Leathers, and Zoas. Just know that you won't be able to keep everything under PC lighting - SPS, Clams (though I wouldn't want to keep a clam in a 29g anyway
), or sea anemones for example. In my honest opinion I would recommend looking at getting T5 lighting. Not many people make a 30" fixture for them, so you might be looking at getting a 36" and just having it hang over the edges of the tank. I suppose you could suspend it a couple inches above the tank as well, though for getting the most out of the fixture I probably wouldn't.
4. Flow Flow Flow - In a 29g you don't have much room, but there is still enough to add some flow. with my 29g I had a Koralia #2 and a Maxi-jet 600 with a rotating deflector (wave maker). Depending on what you want, keep in mind you want to keep water moving in your tank. Not so much that you are making a sand storm, but enough that everything is happy and is getting the required amount of flow.
I hope this helps a little bit. I tend to not get to visit here so often during the summer months
. If I don't reply right away, it's not because I am ignoring you
.
I am sure you are going to get a bunch of "You should do this, you should do that". If you didn't I would be suprised. That's the fun thing about this hobby, everyone is always trying something different, and sharing what worked for them. You can then take all that information and make a decision from there. Welcome to the hobby...get ready to get out the check book
.
 

6mmmedic

Member
Thanks Jubbin!! Lots of great advice! We have actually been in the hobby for close to a year now...my hubby does most of the maintenance on what we have. We have a 55gal and 29gal at home. This new 29gal that I am going to set up will be going to my office at work! I am really excited, just looking for some suggestions. I am afraid my lights will not be enough for much of anything other than fish, but I'm not sure what I will do for lighting yet. I wish I could get bulbs that would fit in the Eclipse, but hubby says he doesnt think I can.
 

jubbin2001

Member
Ahhh the issues with non saltwater kits. Here are a few options.
1. Head to your LFS or contact Marineland and see if you can get a standard glass 29g hood. Probably not going to be to terribly expensive (compared to the costs of LR, ect.
) I contaced one because I shattered mine, and if memory serves, was going to cost about $40 - $50. I instead chose to go with option #2
2. Measure the inside of the aquarium where the hood lays and have a piece of plexy glass cut. My brother happened to have some 1/8" laying around so I used that. I actually just traced it out and trimmed where needed to make it fit. Then I just needed to cut out the required holes for filtration stuff. If your husband and you (or just the husband...which is the case with my wife
) are feeling like a DIY project, this would be it. Menards, Lowels, and Home Depot should have a sheet of plexy suitable fairly inexpensive...though I haven't gone looking lately, so don't hold me to that. Just make sure to attach a plastic (saltwater and metal dont care for each other
) handle of some sort to the top so you can get it off for feedings and maintenance stuff. Super glue works well for attaching handles to plexy glass....as well as one's fingers
.
3. Leave it as an open top and purchase a clip on Metal Halide lamp. A 150w lamp from JBJ (K-2 Viper) will run you about $200. The bennefits - You could put pretty much anything you want into the tank and not have to worry about light requirements, and the really cool shimmering effect from the lights in the water. The bad thing is that the cost of the lamp is the most expensive, and you have to keep an eye out for suicidal fish who wish to reenact the scene from "Free Willy" though in this case it's not to freedom
. You could put some mesh over the tank when you are not around to help keep your would be death wishing friends alive, just remember to remove it when the light comes on or you may have some fire issues, or perhaps some melted subsance that does not infact belong in your tank. Another quick note, corals tend to look drab under straight MH lighting, with out some kind of actinic lights, they just won't flouresce and be kind of boring. Though that is my opinion, it is one that many share. Depending on how your office feels, maybe you could hang the light from the ceiling and get a full MH with the actinics inside...here we are talking about much more money, and probably in this case (since it is an office tank) not really worth it.
4. Buy a retrofit kit. This would involve taking apart the hood, and trying to cram more lights into it (either PC or T5)...though I probably wouldn't recommend it to someone that is just starting and never done a retrofit before. It can be quite a pain, especially when dealing with a pre-manufactured hood. Lots of DIY stuff here, custom work, cutting, ect. The only neat thing would be having the original hood with the tank, if you care about that kind of stuff. Realistically, it might be more of a pain than it is worth.
If it were me, I would stick to option #1. It's going to be the easiest and you could still go with which ever lighting you wish. Though it's still some extra cost, it would probably save yourself (and your husband) many headaches and frustration. Good luck, hope things work out.
 

6mmmedic

Member
Thanks for the suggestions! My hubby is quite the DIY guy, and actually did the plexi glass suggestion with his 55g when we first started. We have had it up and going for close to a year now and he is constantly figuring out better ways to do things with it. Again, thanks for the suggestions!!
 
Top