another impulse buy......

stuckinfla

Active Member
I have read in several posts that when a sponge hits air it dies, thats why LR should be kept in another tank to allow it to die off so it does not poison the tank. Well what happens when you buy a sponge and its in your tank?? I could not resist the color of this, and it has grown in the 2-wks that I have had it.
 

007

Active Member
I am pretty sure thats not a sponge.
It looks like scleranepthia (sp?), or Cauliflower coral.
 

stuckinfla

Active Member
I luv this thing.......WHAT COLOR!!! Anyway, at night it falls all the way over, scrunches up kind of. The pink parts are very prickly, i questioned the LFS, and they said sponge.Who knows, they still have devils hand labled "colt" Stalk is flexible but pink is prickly...I do luv it! Whatever it is.
 

007

Active Member
virtually no light whatsoever . . . seriously. They are a deep water coral.
strong current, and lots and lots and lots of phytoplankton.
These corals do not have a good track record unforunately . . .
 

disgusted

Member
It's a carnation coral and as mentioned it does not have a good track record. Those are shot up with dye or a food coloring substance and eventually it will lose that color. Very pretty for now!!
 

spsfreak100

Active Member
It's a Dendronephtya -- they're impossible to keep. I've never seen anyone successfully keep one. I would return it. I can assure you it will die.
Graham
 

scubasteve

Member
I agree with 007. I have an orange one. They are not photosynthetic, and i've even read they like being hung upside down, or sideways on rockwork (they are often found under overhangs in the wild). I found a different spelling for the scientific name than 007 listed, i'd try to look it up under both (scleronephthya). I moved mine from a lower current to a stronger one, and the polyps really opened up. You are probably going to have to supplement the food source in your water, since it does not use photosynthesis. I've had mine for a month now, and so far so good. Yours is awesome! You got lucky and got one that looks semi-transparent and has great color. Hope it does well in your tank.
Edit: Just looked up the Dendronephtya per SPSfreaks post, and he may be right also. In either case, the physical conditions i listed earlier are valid for both. Both corals are listed as nearly impossible to keep. I took this excerpt from another site:
"Without the symbiotic algae, these corals require a continual wash of phytoplankton across their polyps in order to survive. Dendronepthya hemprichii, sinaiensis and Scleronepthya corymbosa have been found to be almost exclusively phytoplankton eaters, and to actually capture very little zooplankton. This makes complete sense, since phytoplakton is smaller, easier to capture, and these soft corals have relatively undeveloped stinging cells. Thus zooplankton, as previous thought to encompass their main diet, would be hard to capture with such "wimpy" nematocysts. Indeed, captive conditions may be possible using a regular feeding of phytoplankton, however, the amount of food required would still be extraordinarily difficult to cope with in a closed system. "
"In the aquarium, all the amazing properties of Dendronephthya become insignificant. Why? Because they don't survive. Despite massive importation of these corals, many refuse to expand even once upon introduction to captive conditions. They remain in a collapsed state until the tissue dissolves away. Some specimens may adopt a more Goniopora-like pattern where they may expand well for a time, and then slowly begin to expand less and less until they have wasted completely away."
from an article by Eric Borneman

[hr]
Please respect the natural environment that makes this hobby possible. Be responsible and be informed. Support aquacultured/tank raised species.
 

scubasteve

Member
This is a perfect example of how the LFS's don't give enough info to thier customers. You know you have a good LFS if they warn you before the purchase that this is a hard to keep species, and give you a rundown of thier requirements. If your LFS is cool you can ask them to hold a coral for you for a day (or less if they are close) and you can go home and try and research it and see if it is right for your tank, and if you will be able to sucessfully keep it. I was misinformed when i bought mine, and would have sadly left what is now one of my favorite corals in the store had i known exactly what i was buying. I thought about taking it back, but it would probably just die in someone elses tank. So I've decided to do everything i can to keep this coral healthy. All my other corals are currently low maintenance, and I can commit alot of time to this coral. I just hope it's enough. Good luck with yours!
 

stuckinfla

Active Member
The LFS is right around the corner, good advice and holding it for me, then research....I will take it. For now, no more impulse buying....but will keep you posted.
 

scubasteve

Member
Good luck. Hopefully we're both up to the challenge!
By the way, i will be attemting to place mine upside down under an overhang in the new tank. I'll report if this seems to help/hurt. And for anyone who may be curious, my lfs sold this as "tangerine coral".
 
Top