ASM or MSX

[humuhumu1]

Which skimmer do you like more the msx200/msx250 or the asm g-3 for a 150 gallon fowlr.

 

[salt life]

I have an ASM G-1 and it works great, can't comment on the others since I have only had ASM's but if I were to upgrade my skimmer I would stick with ASM.

 

[peter1215]

MSX or Octopus extreme would be my choice.

 

[salt life]

Originally Posted by peter1215
http:///forum/post/3031299
MSX or Octopus extreme would be my choice.

 

[crypt keeper]

I have an asm gx1. Worosk great on my 75. Keep my trates low and water quality near perfect

 

[salt life]

Originally Posted by crypt keeper
http:///forum/post/3031327
I have an asm gx1. Worosk great on my 75. Keep my trates low and water quality near perfect

 

[it's chuck]

MSX / Octo Extreme

 

[jmccown]

These two skimmers are not even in the same category. MSX is worlds apart a much much better skimmer than ASM. I've had both, MSX is one of, if not the best skimmer available today.

 

[pbnj]

Man, I wish I could just run an MSX for comparison. I have an ASM G-3 on my 75g and I can't imagine a skimmer pulling out more than that thing is pulling out already....almost a full skimmate cup per week and the neck is always completely caked.

 

[humuhumu1]

would a msx 300 be overkill on a 150 because i noticed that it only costs $20 more than the msx 250

 

[small triggers]

The more the better i say

 

[hammerhed7]

I have never tried an msx, but I have been an ASM fan for years