Best Protein Skimmer for the Buck?

detane

detane

Member
Word on the Reef is that The ASM is the best for the buck and a lot of LFS use it in their own systems. Needle wheel skimmers also uses a venturi but has the advantage of of the needle wheel in the pump which breaks down the air bubles even finer for better foaming/skimming.
 
J

jojo727

Guest
yea, ASM is well known around the reef world. right now i'm using a turboflotor but i'm planning on getting a new skimmer, one with a recirculating needle wheel pump.
 
joncat24

joncat24

Active Member
BK is always a good choice, but pricey. If I were gonna spend that kind of $$, I would look at the MSX 2s cone skimmer. The cones are wicked!! If I had the $$ I would trade my MSX 250 in for one for sure.
 
detane

detane

Member
Originally Posted by SpendingDough
http:///forum/post/3020918
Any opinions on a BubbleKing mini 200 on a 180G tank?
BK is over priced.. its like when you buy clothing with a brand name on it. Its still the same manufacture making most of the clothig but they add different fancy labels to help market the product better.
 
detane

detane

Member
Octopus Needlewheel Skimmers (NW 150 Large 8" inch)
For Tanks up to 250 gal / Dimensions: 8" X 11.5" X 21.25" / includes a needle wheel pump
$ 224.99
vs.
ASM G Series Protein Skimmers (G-3)
rated up to 250 gallons / base is 11” X 12” height is 25”, dia. is 6.5”/ includes Sedra 5000 pump$ 308.99
 
salt210

salt210

Active Member
the height is stopping me but the octupus sounds good. but will it actually do a good job on a tank up to 250g or should it only be used on one up to say 150?
 
detane

detane

Member
Originally Posted by salt210
http:///forum/post/3021046
the height is stopping me but the octupus sounds good. but will it actually do a good job on a tank up to 250g or should it only be used on one up to say 150?
I use this rule, Buy one that is rated higher than you tank size or double.
 
detane

detane

Member
Originally Posted by salt210
http:///forum/post/3021062
thats the problem that I am running into. I only have 24" to work with down there.
check www.vividaquariums.com this is a local Lfs in my area and they always beat prices and have a large selection of top brand products,, Then watch their Store videos and youll see they know their stuff.
 
oceansidefish

oceansidefish

Active Member
Warner Marine skimmers are newer but IMO are just as good as the ATB skimmers, which IMO is the best you can buy. Warner is also coming out with a cone skimmer very very soon, say a month or so. They also have a true rating....You don't have to double your tank size like with most skimmers. If its says for a 150 it means it....They cost more but work better. Also come with a lifetime impeller warranty.
 
wangotango

wangotango

Active Member
Originally Posted by DETANE
http:///forum/post/3021041
Octopus Needlewheel Skimmers (NW 150 Large 8" inch)
For Tanks up to 250 gal / Dimensions: 8" X 11.5" X 21.25" / includes a needle wheel pump
$ 224.99
vs.
ASM G Series Protein Skimmers (G-3)
rated up to 250 gallons / base is 11” X 12” height is 25”, dia. is 6.5”/ includes Sedra 5000 pump$ 308.99
I'd go with the Octopus before the ASM.
-Justin
 
aquaguy24

aquaguy24

Active Member
Originally Posted by DETANE
http:///forum/post/3021064
check www.vividaquariums.com this is a local Lfs in my area and they always beat prices and have a large selection of top brand products,, Then watch their Store videos and youll see they know their stuff.
sorry to go off topic..but i was planning on visiting their store soon..how are the prices in the store vs. online...
 
detane

detane

Member
Originally Posted by aquaguy24
http:///forum/post/3021672
sorry to go off topic..but i was planning on visiting their store soon..how are the prices in the store vs. online...
prices are better in the store. they also price match and beat prices just to keep you as a customer. One of the best places I have visited. Ocean Pet in Northridge CA is also a favorite of mine, and they BEAT ANY PRICE!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top