Bio-ball alternatives

schippy

Member
I have a 55 gal with a sump below. My nitrates are continuesly high despit water changes. I have been reading allot about bio-balls and feel they must be the problem. I am going to remove them but before I do I have a few questions:
1) should I remove them all at once or gradually? I have heard all at once may crash my tank. By the way I have a deep sand bed with lot's of live rock.
2) What should I put in it's place if anything?
3)I have attached a diagram of my sump set up. Any suggestions for change?
Thanks
Bret
 

stingrayjs

Member
Have your ever cleaned your bio balls? Do they look dirty? Everyone says bio-balls are evil and its just not the the case. If they are maintained they are a very effective at growing benificial bacteria.
 

reefer75

Member
Place some new saltwater in a five gallon plastic bucket, or any other type of good sized deep plastic container. This is where you will rinse and clean the bio-balls off. If you are planning for a water change, water removed from the aquarium may be used for this as well.
Turn off the filter.
Remove about 1/4 of the bio-balls from the filter chamber and place them into the container with the saltwater.
Stir and swish the bio-balls around in the saltwater to break all the gunk or organic matter loose that is stuck on them. If they are extremely dirty, you may have to repeat this step. DO Scoop the rinsed bio-balls out and place them back into the filter bio-chamber. A plastic kitchen colander works great for this, but any type of cup or small container with drain holes in it will do. The bio-balls come out, the yucky water stays behind.
Restart the filter.
Test for the appearance of ammonia every few days for a week, then every several days over another week after that. If the testss read near zero after this time, it is ok to repeat the process. If ammonia does appear, wait until readings drop back to zero, then wait another couple of weeks after that before repeating the process with the next batch of bio-balls.
Tips:
This procedure is suggested to be performed on aquariums that have been running for at least 4 months, because the nitrifying bacteria have had time to develop a strong population, and in all likelihood the bio-balls have begun to accumulate a substantial, but not overwhelming amount of DOCs (Dissolved Organic Compounds) on them.
NEVER use freshwater to clean the bio-balls, and NEVER clean all the bio-balls at once, as this in all likelihood WILL cause your system to crash! Because this procedure strips away and weakens the nitrifying bacteria population present on the bio-balls that the aquarium relies on to keep ammonia and nitrite in check, only clean about 1/4 of the bio-balls during any one cleaning session.
If your system has been running for sometime, say longer than 6 months, with no bio-ball maintenance at all, it may take a little time to get them cleaned up first. After that you can determine when periodic cleanings need to be performed based on how your individual system is set up and functions. You'll learn to know when it needs to be done.
Test for cleaning by lightly stirring up the top layer of the bio-balls. You will see gunk break loose. The only problem here is that in most all cases the mass of the organic matter settles in the bottom layer. You can stir the bio-balls up from the bottom, but be careful doing this because you may get a bunch of gunk shot into the tank if the filter output goes directly into the tank.
This procedure can be used to clean not only bio-balls, but other types of biological filtration mediums as well.
What You Need:
5 gallon plastic bucket
new or used saltwater
plastic kitchen colander
ammonia test kit
NOT scrub the bio-balls! Just allow the saltwater to do the job, nothing more than that.
 

schippy

Member
I appreciate the tips on cleaning them but If I want to remove them How should I go about that and what should I replace them with. Should I use more live rock? Can I build a refug in my current set up?
Thanks
 

reefer75

Member
A fuge may be difficult unless you are willing to take apart and do some modifications. I asume that under the bio balls is a egg crate material. If you want to get rid of the bio balls, Then yes just remove them slowly and carefully, trying not to desturb anything. Then yes you could put in small pieces of live rock.
 

ppurcell

Member
I asked a similar question when I was setting up my new tank. I had a DSB, Plenum, LR and bio-balls. After doing some reading and asking around for advise, I decided to remove the bio balls. I had about 3-4 gallons of bio balls and I removed them all at once without any ill effects, but my tank was very lightly loaded at the time. If you have a heavy bio-load, you will probably want to remove them in stages to allow the bacteria levels to grow in the LS and LR to pick up the new loading level.
 
Top