I have four of those things; I originally had five of them which I purchased for my reef, but I caught them popping the heads off my yellow polyps. Coincidentally, around the same time I was setting up my q.t., so I caught the four that I had and put them in the q.t. I actually used them to help cycle it. I have to say, those guys have seen some nasty days, and the four of them are still tickin'... it's been about six months now... and two of them are huge, the heads of the two big ones are about 3/4 the size of a snapple cap. Anyway, that is what I have noticed about their durability. Why the first one died, I don't know. But, theoretically, they are sensitive to moderate levels of nitrites, and nitrates...so, I would say maybe check those and your ammonia and see if maybe that's it.