flower pot help needed

dad

Active Member
My flowerpot is losing it's polyps. It is about 1/3 bare.
Is something eating them or is this normal?
I have heard they do not live long in tanks?
Thanks
 

blondenaso1

Member
My guess is that it is on its way out. Have you noticed that it hasn't been extending its polyps as much as when you first got it? I have had one for about 5 months now. Don't feel bad, they are very hard to keep which is why I think we should incourage people to read up before they purchase this coral.
 

reeferx

Member
Do you feed it directly?
They need a lot of food to be happy.
Use a turkey baster and do it at the same time everyday so it starts expecting it and opening up beforehand.
Somebody I know actually pulls his out and puts it in a bowl with tank water and feeds it in there so others won't bother it or steal its food.
good luck, hope it turns around...
 

blondenaso1

Member
I don't go as far as taking it out of the tank, but I do agree that direct and indirect feeding is key. I give mine a mix of prime reef and mysis shrimp mixed in with DT's phytoplankton abou every other day.
 

dad

Active Member
Thanks for the info!
It still fans out very large and I do feed it often?
I am replacing my 10,000k MH lamp with a 20,000k next week.
Just maybe this will help?
Thanks again, ;)
 

azonic

Active Member
Maybe your lights are too old? And are losing the proper spectrum? When you feed...does the flowerpot get all the food? Or do fish come running for it.
I remember someone suggested that when feeding them...they had the food in a bowl or container of some kind and when they put the container in the tank they put the container right in over the flowerpot (without letting food get out beforehand), and then all the food in the container goes right to the coral and no fish can get it....I think someone here does that, either that or im dreaming things...
Anyway, good luck with the coral, they are notorious for being hard to keep alive.
 

pyro383

Member
Yes, a person here does it for their sun coral, now the flowerpot is almost like a gorgorian correct. From what I understand is it should not need alot light like a mh and the reefer I bought it from states that. He has kept them both in his home and at his store in med. light
 

u235a4

Member
there is some really good reading at www.fishdomain.com on the flower pot corals and some of the things you will read might supprise you i really though it was good myself...... it help me keep mine alive this long and growing.... 8 months
 

nm reef

Active Member
Goniporas can be extremely difficult to keep long term...I've had one for close to a year now and its still in great shape. I seriously believe that in most systems they simply starve over time due to a lack of proper food in the water column. I feed mine direct with DT's and small bits of the days menu(it seems to like a shot of the juice from the mixture more than actual bits of food)....below is a link with some helpful info on keeping them. They are not a coral for systems set up to offer them a chance to survive.....most information I've seen indicates that the vast majority do not live much longer than a few months.
gonipora success?
 

u235a4

Member
nw what you speak of seems to be true more then light with these it seems they need a constant supply of nutriant rich food...
 

reefkeypr

Member
I agree about feeding. I've had my flowerpot about 8 months now and it keeps growing. Another thing to consider... What about water movement? They need to move their waste. I have mine in a medium flow and it seems to help remove the bad stuff. I also use a wavemaster to shut down my main filtration and powerheads for 1/2 hour to let it eat.It seems to like the normal stuff Brine, mysid, and squid. I feed it with a small amout from a turkey baster it immediatly grabs the goods without time for my fish to steal it from it.
 

flydan

Active Member
Hey,
I'm not so sure about them "needing nutrient rich water". They may be doing well in your tanks, which is great, but that's not what they get in nature. Most of our tanks have a lot more free floating "stuff" (good and bad) than their natural habitat.
Just my .02
Dan'l
 

u235a4

Member
FD i can only say what i have read and works for me which is my opinion and i think that is was dad is after more then anything just to here what has worked for others.....theres no reason to pick apart what someone says.... :)
 

fshhub

Active Member
dad, what are your paramaeters?
they do seem to do better as mentioned in nutrient rich water, their odds of survival are much greater, if your trates are higher, and I believe yours are not(you are too successful with anemones to have the water they need too)
Target feeding may help, but they normally do not do well in tanks, b/c we try to make it too good for them.
HTH
 
Top