Originally Posted by renogaw
..., but it also is their store's website so...
That sums it up folks.
SWF is a for-profit store. not a Non-profit charity.
They provide these forums as a tool to promote the hobby.
I'm sure all of you have jobs. I'm also sure none of you have jobs where a competitor can come into your jobplace, office, etc. and start advertising.
There are a lot of competitor sites out there, yet few provide forums such as these. So, in reality, who is really doing a dis-service to our hobby? This store for wanting to protect it's business interests, or competitors who don't care about providing a forum?
Copyright issues are not based on the rules of SWF. They are the law. We cannot allow people to post copyrighted material. Surely that is not an issue open for debate. Just because something is posted on the web doesn't mean copy/paste is acceptable. Have we grown so lazy as a society that we can't read, comprehend and then type up our own summation? How difficult is it to sum up an article in your own words and put a "thanks to author" citation at the end? countless times I've offered advice on threads and simply stated "according to ____" (Fenner, Calfo, etc.).
Sorry all, but this is a forum to promote the saltwater aquarium hobby to increase business for SWF. I don't believe the rules are going to change.