Freshwater dips-helpful or harsh?

[stephenthepuffer]

The other day while at my LFS, I overheard two people arguing about Freshwater dips and if they are effective. I didn't get to hear the conclusion, so what do you guys think. I've never had to do this before, I wonder if it is an effective treatment?

 

[carrie1429]

I do not think FW dips are effective. I have done this twice and both times resulting in the fish dieing the day after. It is really stressful on the fish and IMO not the best way of treatment. JMO