Glass or Acrylic??

lennon

Member
HI all.
I was reading Fenners book for the 5th time before I made my decision and he highly recommends acrylic tanks instead of glass. Although he says they do scratch easily..He claims that you can take the scratches away from acrylic easily ..but not from glass.
I wanted to do a bow tank but noticed that if you look at it from the side..it tends to get distorted alittle. Would that be the same for acrylic? and has anyone heard of sapphire glass tanks?
thanks much!!
 

bluelagoon

Member
i have an eclipse, so it's acrylic (i guess), and it's slightly bowfront. i've put several small scratches in the front of my tank from my lr, and i don't know how to get them out. how could you get them out of the inside of the tank if you can't put any solutions in there?? and the bowfront does make it hard to see, especially in bigger tanks at the lfs, it gives me a headache just trying to look at them!
 

chipmaker

Active Member
If the tank is scratched form the outside yes, you can use various compounds and methods to remove or reduce the scratching, however a alot of times during this process its also possible to create a worked in optical illusion where the scratches were, which can actually be more of a eyesore than the scratch was itself as they tend to make a ot of distortion........Scratches n the inside would alsmost dictate a tank drain down.
I think anytime a material like glass or acrylic is bent or formed its gonna make optical illusions. My glass bowfront makes it appear to have my vertical filter tube appear to be installed cockeyed, but its not. and a bow front sort of magnifies a bit more than a flat pane does........makes no difference if its acrylic or glass.
I have both, prefer glass and after this past weekend with making the wife a new custon acrylic container for her hermit crabs (Land types) and knowing how carefull she is in what she does, the inside is full of tiny fine scratches just from smoothing the sand down etc.......granted those fine hair scratches would probably not be visible if water was in the tank as water does help hide some scratches, it scratches very easy just the same.........as will glass, but not quite as easy....And yes scratches can be removed from glass but not normally by a home type....I had a large scratch removed from a 90 gal FW tank after I almost lost a large rock I was placeing in the tank, managed to grab it but cold not hold it but managed to wedge and allow it to slide to the bottom instead of busting though the bottom.....I carried the tank to a windshield repair place and had them fill the scratch with the material they use to fix chips and such in windshieds, and its held up perfectly for over 6 years now....OH,m and they did not charge me for the fix, as they were curious as to if it would work and hold up, as it maay mean other walk in business if it worked.......and glass is also able to be worked with various grades of abrasive compounds to reduce or remove scrathces as well, but if not done properly you still run the rish of making a distortion thats worse than the scratch is.
 

lennon

Member
Originally Posted by bluelagoon
i have an eclipse, so it's acrylic (i guess), and it's slightly bowfront. i've put several small scratches in the front of my tank from my lr, and i don't know how to get them out. how could you get them out of the inside of the tank if you can't put any solutions in there?? and the bowfront does make it hard to see, especially in bigger tanks at the lfs, it gives me a headache just trying to look at them!

sorry to hear about your scratch. I am not sure about the inside of the tank..but I know it comes out of the outside somehow. NOt sure how but I read it here.
I guess no bowfront for me..and maybe I should stick to glass...still debating it.
 

offshore80

Member
I have a 175 BF Ocianic. If it was acrylic it would be scratched all to hell from my live rock.
I have a 15" puffer that can push over a 20lb piece of LR from the top of the pile and it will roll down and hit the front of the tank. Luckily it hasn't scratched. I think if it were acrylic it would be scratched up. Not that I'm endorsing Ocianic cause they have other risk.
 

acrylic51

Active Member
Honestly I think it's a personal choice and could be debated on all manners......Acrylic is super nice, clear, easy to work with, and easy to drill......Acrylic is also lighter and a better insulator than glass....BUT....on the other hand glass is just as strong, and is heavier, but will stand up to mistakes with cleaning tools that acrylic just won't take.
If clarity is an issue you can have a glass tank made with Starphire or Low E glass if that is an issue and I had my new tank done in Low E glass for clarity reasons.....I don't care how careful you are with your acrylic tank with time and cleaning you will put scratches in and they are able to be worked out with time and patience, and inside is a different story....You will have to take the tank level down to work them out and imagine coraline algae filling those nice fine scratches and you have a real eyesore then. I take a razor blade to the front panel of my tank and haven't put a scratch in any of my glass tanks, and you have to be a real maniac to scratch a glass tank IMO......for the seams a nice tooth brush from the dentist works just fine......
 
Top