high phosphates = snail death?

V

vinnyraptor

Guest
a buddy of mine has a newly cycled tank. AMMO 0 Nitrate 0 TRite .20 PH 8.0 Temp 80 Grav. 1.023. he added a few snails, hermits and a cleaner shrimp as his initial CUC. dripped them correctly and as soon as the snails and shrimp hit the water they were dead within 10 minutes. the crabs are fine. he did a partial water change and tried another snail, this one from my 3 yr old system and a healthy speciman. dead instantly. two weeks crabs are still fine and 3 attempts at snails and a firefish all dead within minutes.
stray voltage none, Copper none. the only thing is high phosphates how high im not sure he had it tested at a verygood LFS and they told him they were really high, but other than that his water was good. no Copper, Ammo, Nitrate and .20 Nitrite. he used bottled RO water from a giant chain store and has never used tap.
questions are where did the high Phosphates come from and is there a lethal amount that can actually kill inverts within minutes? i know they cause algae and ironically he has none so what gives?
 

luvmyreef

Active Member
I'm not sure about the phos, but maybe its something that you cant test for. Does he run carbon? If not, maybe he should try it. Chemipure would be good. And the phos could be coming from the water source.
 

btldreef

Moderator
.20 nitrites = DO NOT ADD ANIMALS TO TANK.
I wouldn't add anything with a nitrite reading or a phosphate reading. I don't think his tank is completely done cycling. And yes, high phosphates can kill, but more than likely it was the nitrites.
 

geoj

Active Member
Originally Posted by luvmyreef
http:///forum/post/3245201
I'm not sure about the phos, but maybe its something that you cant test for. Does he run carbon? If not, maybe he should try it. Chemipure would be good. And the phos could be coming from the water source.
Many brands of carbon will leach phosphate…
 

luvmyreef

Active Member
Originally Posted by BTLDreef
http:///forum/post/3245203
.20 nitrites = DO NOT ADD ANIMALS TO TANK.
I wouldn't add anything with a nitrite reading or a phosphate reading. I don't think his tank is completely done cycling. And yes, high phosphates can kill, but more than likely it was the nitrites.
Well...I missed that in the post! HaHaHa.
 
Top