how many damsels...

renogaw

Active Member
Ok, odd question i understand :) but how many damsels can i fit into a 20 gallon tank, and what groupings should they be in? and before people think im nuts, i like the coloring on damsels and figure if they are all able to protect themselves because of their bold behavior, why not try it?
 

rbaldino

Active Member
Far from thinking you're nuts, I think that could make for a fun tank. I would think you could house 4 small damsels in a 20, maybe 3 if you want to be on the safe side. I would stay away from getting more than one of any particular kind since that seems to really bring out their aggression. Two I'm sure of would be a yellowtail and a four stripe. You could try velvets and dominoes, but they get kind of big. There are also a lot of blue and/or yellow variations you could try. Good luck!
 

oceanlover

Member
The blue or green chromis are damsels and they are pretty and not too aggressive. Keep them in odd numbers (3, 5, 7) I am told by my local expert.
 

cannonman

Member
I have read and always figure no more than 1" of fish per four gallons to be on the safe side so how many you put in there is completely dependant upon which type you want, one full grown domino damsel could meet the 1" per four gallons almost by itself where as you could have several yellow tailed blue damsels with no problems (other than they will probably fight)
 

sepulatian

Moderator
Originally Posted by renogaw
Ok, odd question i understand :) but how many damsels can i fit into a 20 gallon tank, and what groupings should they be in? and before people think im nuts, i like the coloring on damsels and figure if they are all able to protect themselves because of their bold behavior, why not try it?
Ren, it realy depends on how much rock you have in the 20 and what kind of damsels you want. I have had 2 yellow tails (supposed to be the calmest next to clowns and chromis) fight like hell in a 55. They also do not like new commers. Dominoes and four stripes are two of the most aggressive varieties. I, personally, would get like 3 blue chromis if anything. Damsels can be nasty. Just a heads up.
 

rbaldino

Active Member
Originally Posted by sepulatian
Ren, it realy depends on how much rock you have in the 20 and what kind of damsels you want. I have had 2 yellow tails (supposed to be the calmest next to clowns and chromis) fight like hell in a 55. They also do not like new commers. Dominoes and four stripes are two of the most aggressive varieties. I, personally, would get like 3 blue chromis if anything. Damsels can be nasty. Just a heads up.
I'm guessing the two yellowtails fought with each other, which is why I suggested not getting two of the same kind. In the confines of an aquarium, damsels really don't like having someone else just like them around. Other than that, yellowtails are quite capable of getting along with other fish and other types of damsels. The yellowtail I have now is completely dominated by my green reef chromis (which kind of goes against the common belief that chromis are always peaceful). And four stripes aren't among the more aggressive; their three stripe cousins are. I've kept four stripes with clowns, psuedochromis and other damsels without any real problems.
Anyway, if you get 3 or 4 damsels that are all about the same size and tempermant, they should balance each other out. It might also be a good idea if you could put them all in at the same time, or at least start with whichever one is considered the least aggressive.
 

1journeyman

Active Member
Originally Posted by OceanLover
The blue or green chromis are damsels and they are pretty and not too aggressive. Keep them in odd numbers (3, 5, 7) I am told by my local expert.
They are not peaceful to each other, just other fish. A school of Chromis in a 20 gallon tank will very quickly become 1 Chromis.
Damsels are too territorial to be able to put more than a couple of small ones in a 20 gallon. Many grow large as well so finding small colorful ones may prove to be an issue.
 

renogaw

Active Member
I have three green chromis in my 75, so i don't want any more. So doing a damsel tank isn't all that suggested? I figured they would all be able to defend themselves :(
 

zsqure

Member
I had 2 percs, 7 green chromis, and 3 blue damsels in my 90gal at first. The damsels terrorized my chromis and 3 died of damsel related causes. the damsels are no longer in my tank. Damsels are $4 -$6 for a reason.
 

rbaldino

Active Member
Originally Posted by renogaw
I have three green chromis in my 75, so i don't want any more. So doing a damsel tank isn't all that suggested? I figured they would all be able to defend themselves :(
It's up to you if you want to do it. I think if you get the right damsels and add them in an intelligent manner, there's a very good chance it will work out.
 

slowburn22

Member
Originally Posted by scotty37
How many would be good in a 120 with 150-180lbs of rock?
I would do 7-9 blue/green or blue chromis.
 

rbaldino

Active Member
Originally Posted by scotty37
How many would be good in a 120 with 150-180lbs of rock?
That sort of depends on what else you want in there, if anything else. The important thing for getting a group of chromis to school is to get an odd number and add them all at the same time.
 
Top