I don't know about other MV bulbs but Iwaski last longer. test have been shown that they still run strong after 18mo. Iwaski accually has more blue spectrium than alot of 10k. Especially after 6mo. But they have alot of par in the yellow and green= High par bulb.They are good bulbs. I would only use 6.5k iwaski MV or Ushio,AB, Or radium bulbs. IMo anything German or Japanese. the rest don't test so well. At least under alll the recent lighting test I've seen that they used A spectrodiometer. If they didn't use that or provide data they has used that I wouldn't belive IMO. Just like AB 10k the package say 13k But the test says 8000+ cct. Dunno could have been a bad bulb.... but the variences can be @ 20% +/- My point is you can't go by the manufacture. Go by what looks good, what you like and most important how your corals grow and color.JME