Live Rock

S

sandy

Guest
I have a small aquarium and I am a beginner. I established the tank with two damsels for over 6 months. I then added two small clown perculas and a royal gramma. Everyone is doing fine. Recently I added 20 lbs of cured "live rock" (figi). I was told that it will be good biological filtration. The tank is re-cycling a bit, but with careful monitoring and water changes, everyone is fine. I add calcium for the rock. I do not really have any algae yet except what may have come on the rock. THE QUESTION: I was told to take the activated carbon out of my SKILTER (aeriating filter/protein skimmer) and my Whisper because it would remove the calcium that the rock needs. I put media stones in the Whisper and an extral Fluval foam pad in the Skilter. SHOULD I STILL USE ACTIVATED CARBON or not? Thanks. Sandy :p
 

y2says

Member
I've heard of people having carbon 24/7 and some don't use it at all. I use mine 24/7 as it keeps the water clearer and keeps the smell down.
 

kenobi

New Member
Heres the deal,
CArbon won't bother CA.
Carbon pulls out organics.
Protien skimmer does the same.
Try this pull carbon. If water becomes cloudy and protien skim and bacteria and not working. run caron for 2-3 days.
 
S

sandy

Guest
So, you don't think the carbon will remove the calcium that the rock needs? I would prefer to have carbon, I just don't want to discourage algae growth on the new live rock. Thank you for your response Y2. Sandy
 

fishgod

Member
No the carbon won't pull out the Ca but be careful to use high grade carbon because some of the lower grades leach phosphates back into your aquarium water, and also remember to change the carbon as suggested to aviod re-introduction of some of the organics that it has absorbed!
 

ocellaris_keeper

Active Member
OK - I have never used carbon in my system. My LR is doing great but my water changes are required to keep clean water. MY LFS explained that 2 days or less a week maybe 1 a month will keep the water clean and not lose your trace elements.
try adding some trace elements and you'll be fine.
 
D

diatom

Guest
Sandy~
I know this is way off topic, but your tank is seriously overstocked. Hope you get that new tank up and cycled soon.
D~
 
S

sandy

Guest
Sorry this is long... I'm a newbie.
Diatom... my tank is overstocked? I started with 2 damsels, a whisper filter and and undergravel filter with a powerhead, and the tank cycled. Eight months later one of the damsels died (got up in her fish house (which is no longer in the tank) and died from lack of oxygen. I added 2 small percula clown fishes and a royal gramma. The levels in the tank were normal. I had to give the blue velvet damsel away because he was getting to big and was a bully.
When I added the 20lbs of LR, the fish store said get rid of the undergravel filter because it was an accident waiting to happen. I put two small powerheads at different levels behind the LR to circulate and keep debris from laying in the back. The crushed coral and sand are at about 2" in depth, but not behind the LR. I have a Whisper filter with Fluval Media stones, a Skilter (Protein Skimmer/Dual Filter). I have two Coral Life lamps: 1 50/50 and 1 Full Spectrum Super Daylight.
So what's in the tank: 2 very small yellow-tail damsels, 2 small percula clowns, 1 royal gramma and 1 small (young) purple tang. There are about 4 hermit crabs and 3 snails. There is 23lbs of live rock. (I added two very expensive pieces with a nice algae bed for the snails and to seed the tank).
I've had slight levels of Ammonia and Nitrite because the tank is re-cycling. When I did a 25% water change today -- there was very little extra food debris at the bottom (Hermits doing thier job?. I'm going to re-test tomorrow. I do small water changes all week and 25% on the weekend.
I was told that the Tang will be fine for 6 month to a year before she will need more room. Everyone gets along and there is lots of swimming space.
What do you think?
 

thor

Member
the tang will probably have to be moved before 6mnths, and without it and the damsels you would be ok, also make sure you have plenty of shells for your hermit crabs because if you dont they will kill your snails
 

von_rahvin

Member
the tang does put you over the top. but other than that your tank should be cool. what size tank aare you planning to upgrade to??
 
S

sandy

Guest
I plan to upgrade to minimum 50, maximum 70 gal. Do you think we would be fine for 3 months or so if my levels go to zero? Or will I not even see them go back to zero with the Tang in there? Once I can find a tank (I have little money right now, I'll still need time to cycle it before moving anyone). How hardy are Tangs as far as cycling?
 

karlas

Member
i was running carbon for about 4 months and i dont think it affected the calcium at all because the corraline and halieda alge was growing fine and they both require calcium to grow
 
Top