Hmmm...parrots of the world...been there many times, like you said, great stock, HORRIBLE prices. They're not just high, they're incredible. Case in point: Scarlet cleaner shrimp, 39.99. 'Nuff said.
Check out Fishtown USA in Flushing...you can take the number 7 train from Manhattan to about 2 blocks from it. Excellent, superb stock, prices a LITTLE high, not too bad, but the store is dedicated to just fish, and has everything you could want. Being from the NY area, I gotta tell you though, I buy everything online. The prices here are UNREAL. Be careful tho, bring a compatibility chart or some other reference material with you when you go to Fishtown, because every time you go they have something you never expected to see, and sheesh, you have to resist! By the way, they still have a 2.5 ' Hawaiian Dragon Eel for sale, 499, which is a great price if you have the tank for it.
I'm going Tuesday, my bi-weekly trip, let me know if you guys want to do lunch