Mushroom Coral?

[sparty059]

Can someone tell me what this is? As a matter of fact, while we're at it can you also tell me what #2 is as well? (#2 is top circle, #1 is bottom circle)

 

[slice]

#2 looks like a feather duster to me. I have a couple of similar ones.

 

[sparty059]

Ok, that's what I had thought as well. When I first bought my tank I was under the impression that it was aptasia so I was going to kill it. I decided to leave it be for a while and now just got around to checking. Thank you!
No guesses on #1 though?

 

[monsinour]

#1 looks like a polyp, but dont take my word for it. #2 is a duster.

 

[sparty059]

The picture makes it out to look like that but its not. And that is not an implication that I know what it is because I don't. But confident It's not a polyp.