An excellent store for SW NE Ohio is The Salty Critter, located in Vermilion, Ohio (www.saltycritter.com). I live 150 miles away from the Salty Critter and have found that the trip is well worth the travel time. Good luck.
Stay away from cquarium - they ripped me off for $500 in LR. They were LESS than coperative when I complained! I even sent them pics of the stuff at their request and never heard back from them.
Resurrecting an old thread here...
Thanks to those of you who recommended the Salty Critter. I was in Northern Ohio yesterday and visited. I was very impressed with the quality of their livestock and willingness to assist me in transforming my tank. I've had some of my fish for almost 10 years so finding a place worthy of reselling them was critical to my moving forward. I think I found it! Thanks again.