yor alkalinity and calcium levels wouldnot hrut here either, and as broomer said, check...........
one other thing, at what time do you test your levels(8.6 is still too high, but if it is 8.6 early in the morn, then it prob goes even higher til night, and if it 8.6 in eve, then you only need ot bring it down a little)
also, what tests do you use? if they are strips, i would definitley try another kit