pre mixed water or salt mixes

I have been hearing alot of debate between using pre mixed water or salt mixes in a reef tank, i have been using salt mixes so far but was refered to pre mixed water by friend, dont know what direction I want to go any suggestions.
 

symphony

Member
I have never mixed my own salt water, alway get it from my lfs, they are open 7 days a week till 9pm, so it's easy for me, others my not have that option. oh sorry sunday they close early 6pm.
 

uneverno

Active Member
Welcome
I always mix my own.
To me it's a matter of a variety of factors.
1) Premixed is more expensive
2) I'd have to lug the containers all the way to my apartment from the parking lot (gimme a break, I'm old
)
3) The salinity may not match my tank (they don't mix it exactly the same every time at my LFS, there's just a sign saying what today's SG is)
4) I have to assume that LFS is properly maintaining their RODI machine
In mixing my own, none of the above is a concern.
Downside of mixing your own is that
1) RODI machines are an initial hit, and some are quite expensive
2) Cartridge replacements are also not cheap (my approximate maintenance costs are $200/year for 5 cartridges)
3) it takes ~ 5 hrs for me to get 5 gals of RODI (my machine does 25gpd)
4) I have to have a bucket w/ a powerhead and heater in it churning away for 24hrs before I do a water change.
For me, my own RODI was the logical choice. I'd have the RO, carbon and sediment filters anyway, because I live in an area where the water is bad. Having the aquarium therefore only adds the DI cartridges to my expenses (~ $60/year)
 

symphony

Member
Oh yeah I won't kid ya, lugging those buckets of saltwater sucks!!! I am just lucky to have a store 10 min. from my house, a truck, and since I'm a girl they usually feel sorry for me and load my buckets for me
I have a nano tank so I don't go through water that fast, more RO water for top off than anything.
 

don trinko

Member
for me it's the money; Premix is over $1 a g. I buy 160g of salt mix for less than $50. I had ro anyway. If you bought ro it is abought .35 a g here. Don T.
 

bizzmoneyb

Member
i used to buy the pre mixed water at my LFS. what a PAIN. lugging those jugs back and forth.
now i have an RO/DI unit and do it myself. the salt and RO unit cost money up front, but will def save in the long run. plus i can choose my salt as opposed to having to use what the LFS used.
but you have a small tank so it will probably tank along time for you to start saving.
 
Top