QUARANTINE TANK PROBLEM

david mallette

New Member
HI
I AM A 54 YEAR OLD MALE, LIVING IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. I'M NOT VERY COMPUTER SAVY, SO I HOPE THIS GOES WELL. THIS IS MY FIRST "CHAT ROOM" EXPERIENCE. I WAS RECENTLY BIT BY THE MARINE AQUARIUM BUG. I'M IN MY 4TH MONTH, AND I AM TRYING TO DO THIS RIGHT. GOOD WATER QUALITY,WEEKLY WATER CHANGES (RO WATER),PROPER LIGHT, SPARSE FEEDINGS, PROPER ADDITIVES, ETC,
ETC. I AM HAVING TROUBLE KEEPING FISH ALIVE IN MY QUARANTINE TANK. MY MAIN TANK SEEMS HAPPY.
MY QUARANTINE TANK IS: 12 GALLON ECLIPSE
WITH: WET/DRY BIO WHEEL
STOCK- FULL SPECTRUM DAYLIGHT
FLUORENCE LAMP
7 LBS LIVE ROCK
1" SUBSTRATE
1- CLEANER SHRIMP
MY MAIN TANK IS: 50 GALLON
WITH: 50 LBS LIVE ROCK
1" SUBSTRATE
RIO 1700 PUMP
WET/DRY FILTRATION W/PLASTIC BIO MEDIA
VENTURI STYLE PROTIEN SKIMMER W/RIO 600
2-96 WATT FULL-SPECTRUM VHO FLUORESCENTS
2-CLARK II CLOWNS
1-BLUE DAMSEL
1-SARGENT DAMSEL
1-CLEANER SHRIMP
2-FIRE SHRIMP
2-LONG TENTACLE ANEMONES
5-SNAILS
2-COLT CORALS
1-BUBBLE CORAL
1-STAR POLYP COLONY
1-FLOWERPOT CORAL (GONIOPORA)
5-10 ASS. VOLUNTER MUSHROOM ANEMONES
2-FEATHER DUSTERS
2-HERMIT CRABS
THE MAIN TANK SEEMS FINE. I HAVE LOST A FEW FISH, BUT EVEN THE HARD TO KEEP FLOWERPOT CORAL IS VERY HAPPY. IN THE LAST MONTH AND A HALF, IN MY QUARANTINE TANK, I HAVE LOST:
1-YELLOWHEADED SLEEPER GOBY
1-FIREFISH
1-ROYAL GRAMMA
3-TOMATO CLOWNS
1-3 SPOT DAMSEL
1-FIRE SHRIMP
NONE MAKE IT THROUGH THE 2 WEEK QUARANTINE. MOST DON'T MAKE IT 3-5 DAYS. I AM DOING WEEKLY WATER CHANGES USING THE WATER FROM MY MAIN TANK. I TEST THE WATER FREQUENTLY,AND HAVE HAD TWO OF MY MARINE SUPPLY STORES TEST IT ALSO. BOTH OF THEM SAID MY WATER QUALITY WAS FINE. I HAVE NOTICED THAT THE GREEN ALGAE IS NOT AS ABUNDENT,ON THE VIEWING SURFACE, IN THE QUARANTINE TANK AS IT IS IN THE MAIN TANK.
LAST WEEK I HAD A NICE LOOKING TOMATO CLOWN THAT SEEMED VERY HEALTHY,SO I GOT IT A LTA. THE CLOWN ACCEPTED THE ANEMONE IN 4 HOURS AND LOVED IT. TWO DAYS LATER THE FISH WAS DEAD. I REALLY HATED TO LOSE THAT ONE! I HATE TO LOSE ALL OF THEM! THE ONLY THING IN THE QUARANTINE TANK IS A LONELY CLEANER SHRIMP.
ANYWAY,I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO.SHOULD I KEEP TRYING WITH MORE NEW STOCK? SHOULD I LET IT GO FALLOW AWHILE?
ANY AND ALL OF YOUR COMMENTS WILL BE APPRECIATED. THANKS
DAVID MALLETTE
 

fmarini

Member
David:
No offense but a 12gal tank is small. especially when you subtract water for live rock, etc.
For equal or less money you spent on that eclipse you could have gotten a 30gal rubbermaid tub, a sponge filter, and air pump.
Neverthe less
I'm not sure whats killing your fish in the qtank, but my guess is that your Qtank is only cycled for live rock and a shrimp and when you add a fish you have an ammonia spike in a few days. Your best bet when adding fish to the Qtank is to change 25% of the Qtank water w/ the main tank daily or every two days. Also measure the water parameters in the Qtank, and if you leave the sponge filter in your sump of the main tank then its ready to go at any time.
My opinion
frank
 

david mallette

New Member
Sorry about the caps, I'm new at this. Quarantine tank is:
Temp= 78
SG=1.023
Ammonia=0
Nitrite=0
Nitrate=20
Calcium=400
I'm using B-Ionic every other day.
Thanks
 

david mallette

New Member
You guys could be right. Maybe my quarantine tank has not cycled. Should I wait awhile? Why would my marine supply store say my water quality is ok? Could I put some harty damssels in?
 
Top