A plenum system is a deep sand bed (DSB) (3-4 inches deep) on top of an undergravel filter (plenum) that has been capped off, not allowing water to enter through the lift tubes.
This creates a dead water space underneath the sand. It is much safer than a DSB without a plenum because there is less chance of anaerobic bacteria growth, which will crash your tank.
In both a DSB and a DSB with a plenum, oxygen diffuses down through the aragonite sand providing oxygen to the low oxygen bacteria which process solid waste and remove nitrates. Since a plenum DSB system has a mass of low oxygenated water below the plenum, oxygen diffusion is greater than a DSB system without a plenum and therefore safer.
If you have too much of your LR covering the top of your sand bed then you reduce oxygen diffusion and raise the chance of anaerobic bacteria, sulfur and death. This is why some people have moved away from DSBs. This is far less likely when using a plenum with your LSB.
If your PH drops too low the aragonite sand dissolves providing an excellent buffer, also adding calcium to the water.
It is important to start out with relatively clean water under your plenum. If you have been using an under gravel filter for several months or years, then you probably have accumulated a lot of solid waste in the water under your under gravel filter. Shutting it down and capping it would probably cause your tank to crash.
Plenums have been around for about 8 years but have been underutilized by aquarists largely due to equipment vendors and pet stores not pushing them because they are very inexpensive and when using a DSB with a plenum, you don't need wet/dry filters, sumps, refugiums, UV sterilizers and other expensive equipment that make more money for vendors and pet stores.
Its best to use a plenum DSB system with live rock, a protein skimmer or both.
Having said all this, it is true that there are many roads that lead to successful filtration.
This is my road, mainly because I believe this hobby will grow rapidly if systems are simple and less expensive.
Proof that plenums work well is evident by the fact that you won't find many people (including many on this forum) that have used them saying that they don’t work.
For more on plenums see: <a href="http://saltaquarium.about.com/cs/livesandsetup/" target="_blank">http://saltaquarium.about.com/cs/livesandsetup/</a>
I know of one vendor that sells inexpensive plenums. Contact me for more info…
Hope this helps,
Rick
mcsac@msn.com