running carbon......

hlcroghan

Active Member
Okay, I keep hearing conflicting information about running carbon in tanks, more specifically reef tanks. Is there something wrong with doing this? I have one side of my filter running carbon all the time and have not noticed any adverse effects.......although my tank is not extremely mature. Is it bad for corals or fish? Does it interfere with nutrients?? You are feeing the corals food anyway right? i turn my filter off for about an hour when I feed my tank at night so everything an eat without having to add tons of food to the tank to make up for the stuff that gets sucked into the filter. Just want to know what the experts think about it.
 

blkhawk10

Member
I run carbon all the time and seem to have no problems with any corals, I only have a few though, if that means anything.
 

hlcroghan

Active Member
i don't have a lot yet either......my coralline is growing like crazy. There has to be calcium and other elements present for that but I keep hearing how people say you should not run carbon but then others do all the time. Maybe you should only when the tank is just starting out and give it a chance to handle bioload???
I am definitely confused on the issue.
 

bs21

Member
Carbon ias fine to run it does remove some trace elements.....not calcium but others but algae and other things will remove more than carbon. if keeping corals though you can always supplement these. On a side note what you want to look at is what the carbon is made from (wood, lignite coal, etc....) IMO the best is the lignite coal but you also want to consider that carbon can not just take things from the water but also release things like phosphate. What i think is best is to get a phosphate test kit fill with RO water and put drops of test solution in tube then drop in a piece of carbon. If you see color streaks coming out of carbon then it is putting phosphates in the water. this is why i am hesitant to buy cheap carbon.
Also carbon needs to be placed in an area where water is forced through it and not able to just go around it. Besides just binding certain pollutants in the water to it another benefit is that it is also porous and acts as miniature LR where bacteria can colonize it (may be minute and pointless when considering size of tank and LR etc... but every bit helps....can't hurt). I like to run carbon regularly. IMO using for a couple days here and there does nothing but help remove yellowing compounds from the water which could possibly be detrimental to corals because more light is let through then..... but if thats what you want to use it for then fine but as far as a source of chemical filtration you should use more regularly.
i'm sure you weren't looking for an in depth rant like that but carbon is one of those things that comes with multiple different opinions on how, when, why, if ever, it should be used so i elaborated. hope it helps.
 

pbnj

Member
I run Seachem carbon all the time in a canister filter along with phosphate pads. Carbon loses most of its effectivesness after about 2 weeks. I only replace it once a month too, but I rinse out the carbon bags and phosphate pads when I clean the filter 2 weeks between changes.
I only supplement the tank with a few of capfuls of Seachem Reef Complete twice per week. Calcium is always adequate and water is crystal clear. This is going on about 6 months now.
 

hlcroghan

Active Member
I had a long talk with my lfs store guy that I talk to. What a wealth of info he is!! Such an awesome guy......Anyway, he said to stay away from the carbon completely due to phosphates and always go with the chemipure elite because it lasts longer and is more effective because it changes the chemical compounds of the nitrate but I may do both.....not sure yet. He said it is really not necessary to use carbon at all but it is hard to break a habit that I have had for almost 10 years now. And.....I don't have phosphates at all in my tank so.........maybe the cartridges are working well for me?? I am thinking of doing both......
 

pbnj

Member
You know, I tried Chemipure Elite because I heard it was very good, but no matter how much I rinsed the bag, it always seemed to have a significant discharge....I discontinued using it.
 

pbnj

Member
Two separate containers....wasn't willing to see if the 3rd time was a charm. Carbon plus a phosphate pad will work just fine.
 

drewdog82

Member
I'm just getting back in the hobby after being out for a little over a year, but in my 55 reef I didn't run carbon for the first year of the tank and then was talked into using it. The main difference I noticed was the water did become a bit clearer. I ran the carbon for a week out of each month and went without carbon for the rest of the month...
 
Top