starfish:reef safe/easy to care 4

bill109

Active Member
heyy
can anyone sugest a good starfish for my 90 gall reef?
i have about 60-90 lbs of lr and the tank has been set up for over a year but the rock is roughly 3 years old, coming from my existing tank..
so let me hear what ya got!
thanks in advance.
 

dgonci

Member
Since you havent gotten a reply yet, let me see if I can help. I got a small reddish orange starfish that only gets about two inches across, that I has told was reef safe. The guy who sells them actually keeps them in his frag tank when he gets them in. I have had mine for a few weeks now with no problem. Unfortunately I can not remember the name. When I talk to the guy tomorrow I will repost. No pis eaither as he has been on he back side of the live rock for a bit now.
 

fishygurl

Active Member
Originally Posted by dgonci
http:///forum/post/2704351
Since you havent gotten a reply yet, let me see if I can help. I got a small reddish orange starfish that only gets about two inches across, that I has told was reef safe. The guy who sells them actually keeps them in his frag tank when he gets them in. I have had mine for a few weeks now with no problem. Unfortunately I can not remember the name. When I talk to the guy tomorrow I will repost. No pis eaither as he has been on he back side of the live rock for a bit now.
sounds like those little fromia stars(i believe is what they are called).. they dont live very long they are more of a rental type thing..
You can try a linkia star these are reef safe.. As for easy to care for i wouldnt know. I know you should have a tank set up for 6-8 months at least, also have lots of rock and not a really tiny tank. Also you have to drip acclimate them for like i think it was 4-5 hours or so..
Hope i helped, and hopefully some people with more knowledge in starfish will jingle in.
 

mr_x

Active Member
i think you are speaking of a red bali star. they eat coralline algae. if that's ok with you, i think they are fairly easy, but i think the easiest star to take care of is a banded serpent star. they will take food from your hand and also clean up what the fish don't eat.
 

bioneck47

Member
I haven't had luck with any of the reef safe stars. I've tried linkias, fromias, and sand sifters. I had a red bali star live for almost a year, but that's about it and my 90 gal reef is very well established (been up and running for 6 years now).
 

teresaq

Active Member
I have a dark burnt orange brittle star that is doing reat so far. just hangs out under the rocks and eats food.
T
 

jtrzerocool

Active Member
i have a black brittle starfish that i have had about 8-9 months now...it is doing great and it cleans up all the left over food on the sand...its fun to look at and when people see it they think its the coolest thing...
 

dse

Member
Originally Posted by jtrzerocool
http:///forum/post/2704806
i have a black brittle starfish that i have had about 8-9 months now...it is doing great and it cleans up all the left over food on the sand...its fun to look at and when people see it they think its the coolest thing...
+1 on brittle starfish reef safe and move fast watching it wrigle frozen mysis up its legs is probably the most strange but fascinating thing to see mines also black.
 

mr_x

Active Member
brittle stars are known fish eaters though.....i don't know where you are getting "reef safe" from. they will eat anything they can capture.
 
L

lsu

Guest
Originally Posted by Mr_X
http:///forum/post/2705053
brittle stars are known fish eaters though.....i don't know where you are getting "reef safe" from. they will eat anything they can capture.
I always thought that it was only the green brittles that were notorious fish killers. As for reef safe and "easiest" to care for I'd go with a serpent.
 

jtrzerocool

Active Member
Originally Posted by Mr_X
http:///forum/post/2705053
brittle stars are known fish eaters though.....i don't know where you are getting "reef safe" from. they will eat anything they can capture.
yes...green brittle stars are known fish eaters...however the black ones are widly concidered "reef safe"
 

dgonci

Member
Fishygurl was correct...It is a fromia star I have. I have not had any issues with it and my corals at all. Just hangs out on the rock for the most part. Even if it ends up being short lived it was $10, so not a huge loss.
 
A

alexmir

Guest
Look up harlequin serpent starfish. Its a blask and white striped serpent star,reef safe, easy, REALLY pretty. I have one and can feed it from my hand. Not dangerous like brittles, which can catch and eat sleeping or weak fish.
 
Top