Sump Situation

azaintcold

Member
I have a 150 gallon. The only tank I can fit under the tank is a 29 gallon because its already set up and thats all that goes through the door of my stand. I would obviously prefer more water volume if possible. I am going to make a sump/fuge out of this 29 gallon. My question is this:
Is this going to be a sufficient size, or is there a better solution that you handy people can think of?
 

dhughesz28

Member
How many overflows do you have?
Many people have two tanks that make up thier sump system, one for the refugium and the other for the skimmer. mabye you could use 2 20gal tanks instead of trying to fit one large tank under there.
 

scsinet

Active Member
The two tank idea by hughes is probably your best bet.
The generally accepted minimum size for a fuge is about 10-15 percent of your total system volume.
If you dedicate a tank to your fuge and one to your return, you'll be in good shape.
Have you investigated othersizes, such as breeder tanks, to see if maybe you can get more depth (front to back) so as to fit more gallonage in there?
 

azaintcold

Member
Originally Posted by SCSInet
The two tank idea by hughes is probably your best bet.
The generally accepted minimum size for a fuge is about 10-15 percent of your total system volume.
If you dedicate a tank to your fuge and one to your return, you'll be in good shape.
Have you investigated othersizes, such as breeder tanks, to see if maybe you can get more depth (front to back) so as to fit more gallonage in there?
Oh believe me, I've investigated all options and even a custom made tank to use all the room I can to squeeze it through the door would only be a 35 gallon or so.
I'm a little lost on how this would work with two tanks, would it work with one overflow and one pump or is this totally out of the question? Also would there be more of a risk of flooding with this type of a set up ? I know all about the anti-syphon hole etc. Thanks for your time.
 

azaintcold

Member
The generally accepted minimum size for a fuge is about 10-15 percent of your total system volume.
I just noticed this statement. That would be about 15 - 22 gallons for a fuge... So would it be "okay" with a 29? Or would you go bigger. SCS you seem well educated on aquariums especially when it comes to DIY things, so your opinion will have a heavy sway on what I do.
 

scsinet

Active Member
If you wanted to use two tanks, the easiest way to do it is to drill both tanks and put a bulkhead in, then install a pipe joining the two tanks together.
I've also seen it done where people just hang a U-tube over the edge of both tanks, and the siphon keeps the water levels even... but if the water level ever should drop to where the siphon breaks, you'll flood.
A 29 split in half will give you two 15g sections, which will make for a decent fuge and you'll be right at 10%.
Here is another thing you could do...
Put a 29 on one side, as your fuge, then put a 20L on the other as your skimmer/return. Then take advantage of the 29G's extra height to simply drain over the top into the 20L return section by just intsalling a bulkhead and elbow.
This will allow you to divide the drain from the tank into a skimmer and fuge section, allowing you to control the flow through the fuge, and having a separate skimmer section allows you to keep the skimmer from skimming fuge effluent, something you don't want.
I attached a professional-looking graphic to illustrate.
Though if you aren't in for the effort, a 15g fuge should be sufficient, but this would allow you more flexibility if you want.
 

azaintcold

Member
I see. I think thats what I'll do. I think that drawing works perfect. I'll add a bubble trap and call it a day. Appreciate your help!
 
Top