I agree, starfish are a little creepy...
but, i find eels to be VERY creepy.... YIKES! i bought my room mate one for his birthday and couldn't look at it... had to have the fish store people put it in a brown bag so i couldn't see it, then have a friend carry it out of the store...
the fish tank was in my room, close to my bed.. one night it got out, i heard it hit on the floor adn then heard it crawl over some papers that crinkled... i didnt' know what it was, so i looked down and saw it crawlign toward me in the middle of the night...
i still have nightmares about it...