So to bring the topic back around...
I marked "DVR" but I think you were referring to the generic DVR cable boxes and satellite boxes that are out there.
I personally just got rid of my ReplayTV (Tivo's biggest competition before they went under
) in favor of a Windows Media center.
Since you are slamming everything that is "not Tivo", I think I'll play my trump card
. Frankly, Tivo SUCKS in comparison, and I think you'll agree when I explain what it can do.
I've got one big Media center server. It runs Windows Vista Ultimate, and has 4 tuners on board. Two analog tuners that connect to two Dish Network receivers for recording satellite, and 2 ASTC tuners that pull in off-air HDTV from my antenna. I have 1000GB of recording space (about 1000 hours of analog or 300ish hours of HDTV). The media center runs extenders on TVs around the house that connect to it throught my network, so every TV in the house can watch any of the 4 tuners, schedule recordings, or view any of the centrally stored recordings.
Advantages?
- DVD Storage. I can place DVDs into the drive on the server and copy them to the hard drive, and play them back on any TV in the house at any time, without using the disc.
- I can download movies off the Internet, and simply place them on the Media center's hard drive and play them anywhere in the house. (Of course you should always do this legally...
)
- Games - You can install game emulators and run playstation, Dreamcast, Nintendo, just about any games, on any TV. I don't do this though.
- Extenders - each one connects another TV to the system and allows access to everything. If I'm watching a show and decide to go to bed, I can stop it in the living room, go to the bedroom, and pick it up right where I left off in the other room.
- Multiple tuners - I can record 4 things at once, or record two things, watch TV on two more, etc.
- No subscription fees.
- Upgradeable hard drive space, etc as time goes on. This is possible with a Tivo but it voids the warranties.
- Streamable - I can stream recorded content from my media center PC to my computer at work if I brownbag lunch, etc.
- I can burn any shows I record off to DVD for permanent storage.
- I can back up my media center at any time.
... so... let's see your Tivo do those things. And no, you don't have to be a technical geek (though I am... ) to set this up. You can buy everything you need off the shelf. It is much more expensive than Tivo, but once you make the initial investment, it's well worth it. The nice thing is that you can scale the system as you go, you don't have to buy everything right away.
So let me officially state via emoticon:
For the record though... I will NEVER go back to TV without a DVR/TIVO/MEDIA CENTER type setup again. Once you go DVR, you'll never go back!