I just took a look at my overflow and it looks like it's about 1/4". If you have a Dremel, you could drill the hole at the bottom of the tooth and then cut the sides of the tooth with the Dremel using one of the large rouind disks. Lacking a Dremel, there are drill bits that are supposed to be able to be used as side cutters. Keep an eye on the drill bit-as it gets hot it will start melting the plastic and it can get kinda messy.