Let me say this. Those little things have stayed that small since we have gotten that frag of pink people eaters. I hate to say it but, we do have a majano growing next to that frag on the bigger base rock. The majano started smaller than these things and is now almost dime sized. I can say with certainty that these 2 things are not the same. Besides, there is a "star" shaped hole next to these things where more used to be. The urchin ate it a while ago. I will see if I can get a pic of that today.