What type of water should I use to fill up my tank?

makofury

Member
The last couple of times I set up my tank I used hose water from outside, since my tank is in the living room and it's really convenient to use the hose. My question is if it's better to use pre-made saltwater from a LFS, normal water from inside the house, or distilled water that I could buy from a store? Thanks.
 

misty

Member
Oh...first off, what's in your tank already? The reason I ask is because I think that there is some coating on the inside of normal garden hoses that isn't good for fish/tanks (fresh or salt). Just what I've heard from numerous sources...
Next, I think it's best to do water changes and top-offs with fresh/salt RO water from your LFS. You can get fresh and mix it yourself or you can get saltwater and just put it in for water changes.
Just remember, top-off with fresh RO water and do water changes with saltwater (premixed salt RO or DIY with fresh RO and salt mix).
Water from your local water source (tap/hose) contains harmful metals and other pollutants, and can add phosphates/nitrates, and a whole bunch of stuff you probably don't want to know about since you drink it!
 

makofury

Member
Right now there is absolutely nothing in the tank, there are 3 20 lb bags of nature's ocean live sand waiting to be put in once i fill up my tank, so right now there is nothing in my tank.
 

oceanblue

Member
Mako,
To answer your question in short. It is better to get the water from your lfs than to use tap water generally speaking. The problem is that tap water can contain numerous additives that make the water safe for human consumption...but we are far more tolerant than many other species. You'd also be surprised at what's considered "safe" for human consumption...ask for a water makeup report from your local water company and you'll see what I mean. Anyway, maybe I can better explain through another experience I had. I have always loved discus ( a freshwater fish considered difficult in the hobby.) I had always used tap water for all my tanks without serious affect, then I moved states, and continued the same practice, only to be slapped in the face when the water company did it's usuall spring and summer phosphate water treatments, needless to say the fish went from happy to clamped fin, irregular breathing, and regardless of how much water I changed it didn't get better. So, after a friend and I lost breeding pairs and young precious favorite friends, and hearing through the lfs that this was the worst one to date, and that they as well as many people accross the town lost fish due to the extreme levels used, I guess so high that even their huge R/O system only cut them down. So, I had two choices, buy an expensive R/O unit to at least buffer against these kinds of problems, or learn the water companies patterns and continue on. I chose a middle road, got a less expensive DI unit, and studied the water companies chemical usage after getting reports for a year, and getting info from the lfs who talked directly to them. My sticking with tap water was decided by one factor, and that is without any chemical additions(outside the usual chlorine) our tap water is really pure...I've had exhaustive testing done a number or times, working with the lfs. anyway, unless you're willing to go to this extent finding out what and how much and when the water company is dumping, it would be far safer either buying the water or at least getting a good DI unit for your tap. Do realise that marine tanks are far more sensitive than freshwater tanks in general, and everything is worth more(financially and morally). In the end Misty is barking up the right tree. You don't want distilled as that is totally devoid of anything, and you don't want tap, you want something "just right"..kinda sounds like a nursery rhyme. The point is to KNOW for sure what is going in so you have control. The best scenario for control is R/O being next to distilled in purity. I've said alot, and will let some other's speak, have fun with it! Dave
[ August 06, 2001: Message edited by: OceanBlue ]
;)
[ August 06, 2001: Message edited by: OceanBlue ]
 

misty

Member
Wait for input here from someone more experienced before you do anything, but my thought leans toward removing the water that came through the garden hose and replacing with tap or RO water. I know, lots of buckets and a general pain in the rear!
I started my tank with treated tap water (dechlorinated, mixed the Instant Ocean in myself) but will do all of my top-offs and water changes with RO water from my LFS.
 

flydan

Active Member
Hey,
You want to use RO water. Declorinated tap water still has traces of copper that are deadly to a marine aquarium and almost impossible to get out once introduced to your tank. I had to fill a 55gal tank from scratch and my lfs let me borrow several 6gal plastic gas cans that he uses for RO water only. I've since gotten some myself, at Walmart I believe, that I get filled up at the lfs. It may take you several trips to fill up your tank, but the patients you use now will be well worth the effort. Take your time and do it right the first time. You wont be sorry! HTH
Take care,
Dan'l :D
 
Top