which wet dry filter do i get

[ken940]

i have been looking at two different filters a toms rapid pro ps4 and a pro clear 150 gal both have a built in protien skimmer the ps4 is a little higher

 

[elite]

i was also planning on buying that setup any one have any experience with them?

 

[brodweiser13]

Not sure if this is helpful anymore as you posted in Feb., but I've had that set-up running for 16 months now. From a water chemistry standpoint, I've yet to have any problems. pH holds at 8, amm at zero, nitrates at 0, and nitrites around 10. Also, the auto refill is great.
However, it does have some issues. The skimmer is useless, so I have a HOB Aqua C. Also, I've always had an issue with micro-bubbles that I haven't been able to solve. I've raised the water level in the sump of the filter but I still get air.