Had a crab that looked alot like an emerald but had flat legs, I assume for swimming. He would hide in my rock and was actually in the tank for two months before I saw him. Little sucker totally cleaned one rock of all coraline, had large, large pinchers and was brownish red in color with red eyes. Hadnt attcked anything but he ate all my coraline and I wasnt risking it. Played it safe and fed him to my puffer. Whenever I cannot identify anything in my tank I always play it safe and remove them. Also, if you cannot identify something and are worried but want to keep it until you identify it you can take one of those cheap gladware tupperware containers (the small ones), puncture some holes in the sided and bottom, put the crab (or whatever) in it and sink it to the bottom of your tank. Like a little holding cell while you work on id.