kiddow got it right, they grow the new one under their shell, so when they molt they then have both claws again. Sometimes it takes a few molts though before the claw reappears. It does not grow like a little claw that slowly grows back to normal size, just not there one day, then there the next. It is pretty neat, I think. Hard to believe they can fit the whole claw under their shell. However, the new claw and the rest of the new shell is still soft until a few hours after the old shell has been molted. It is during this time that the food industry harvests the crabs that become "soft-shell crabs."