I want to remove the lid because there is only about 1 inch of space between the surface of the water and the glass lid. My Oxygen levels are very low and I think part of the problem is that there is not enough room for gas exchange. I think the 1 inch space above the water is probably filled with CO2. Removing the lid would help, I think.
Also, I'm planning on getting a metal halide light and would like to hang it from the ceiling over the tank. The lid would get in the way, build up heat, and block some of the light from entering the tank. My LFS is a big advocate of lidless aquariums.
Hmmm... I do have a cat. Do you really think it would fall in an open tank?