Search results

Originally Posted by 1journeyman I don't need a scapegoat. I just want all the facts presented. You can't say all of your inverts were fine when one died... From your Clam post it is clear you didn't think it was sick as you suspected your snail killed it. I've emailed Chem Marin with my...

only i know how my clam was when i bought it... it is MY clam that died, yet im not blaming this med.. u all need a scapegoat.

Originally Posted by robn mujtba, I thought maybe you had called the company and asked them......but then, they might not tell you anyway because it would be giving away their "trade secret" I know that when you have a fish in hypo the ich literally burst due to the low salinity and osmotic...

Originally Posted by 1journeyman That's incorrect. The title of the thread doesn't say "here's how I got rid of Ich". The original poster's tone was one of "This works, quit doing all that other stuff". (For instance "Yes I know, QUARANTINE, REMOVE FISH FROM TANK blah blah blah for a month blah...

unfortunately i don't know the full details.. i just know after applying it, none of my corals or inverts were harmed.. even today its fine, as u saw my tank video.. i am giving this med the benefit of the doubt.. the company says the parasites fall off and attach to the false hosts and get...

Originally Posted by robn o2ngk, I agree completely.....as I stated several times, I really believe the original poster was genuinely trying to be helpful. If it seems like it helped, then I say great! If it added more slime coat to a fish, that in itself is a good thing. I have more of a...

Originally Posted by psusocr1 i love stop parasite! that stuff is awesome when used with good husbandry and other various methods...Its not only removed ich from my fish on two occasions but on one particular i thought my blue hippo would certainly die within 12 hours thats how bad she looked...

Originally Posted by renogaw yea, i'm surprised it hasn't been closed. heck, even someone who hasn't been on the boards in over a year (except to try to sell off her tank...odd) came on to say this stuff worked. Wow, instead of just thanking me for posting my success and SHARING my stories, I...

Originally Posted by 1journeyman Mujtba... You cannot responsibly assume Ich is gone from a display aquarium within weeks of an outbreak. Furthermore, your CLAM DIED. Mujtba, I'm not trying to argue with you, but I do want you to understand the life cycle of the parasite you are dealing with...

Originally Posted by Beth 1journeyman, you've said everything that can be said with precision accuracy. The fact that so many feel one way, and 2 feel the other way, says it all. It may work, but it may not. Its not reliable and there could well be long term negative effects on your system and...

I already told you its been working GREATTT for me.. Crimzy told you he has been good for years.. if Chem Marin went public, Id be buying all their stocks.. lets just say that. Remember, when a company releases a product, they go thru EXTENSIVE studies before going to the public. its a HUGE...

Originally Posted by Clown Boy You may be right, Mujtba. Let's just say for a moment that you are. I think you are taking the wrong approach to presenting your discovery. Calling people not close-minded is not the way to go about it... even if you are right. Also, if you leave this hanging...

Originally Posted by rbaldino Hey, if everything is still going good in six months or a year, I'd think you'd want to come back and rub it in. nope! thats where your're wrong... im gonna leave this hangin in the air.. Originally Posted by Beth Its all just a part of being passionate...

Originally Posted by rbaldino I don't think that you can claim unparalleled success after only five weeks, especially when you just had a clam die. Come back in 6 months and again in a year and tell us how things are going. And my QT is only 5.5 gallons and certainly not taking over my...

like i said, EVERY other person says ICH IS ALWAYS IN THE TANK!!!! cmon now MR KNOWITALLS!! keep up w me!

bacterial infections lead to STRESS, which leads to ICH... yes its true.

theres more than 1 product on chem marins page. his site is so sloppy.. you have to read it ALL thoroughly to see what he speaks of and refers to. i was confused at first too, til i read it all.. he talks about several products in one breath and it loses people.

Originally Posted by 1journeyman That can't happen in my tank. I run a QT. I understand the life cycle of Ich. There is NO ICH in my tank. So that's not an issue. From your post, it seems you believe this medication replaces proper QT. There are a lot of reasons other than Ich to QT.... Mujtba...

BOTTOM LINE: don't knock it, till you try it.. thats like me saying 'QT IS NOT GOING TO WORK. THE MINUTE I PUT MY FISH BACK TO MY DT, HE WILL GET STRESSED AND ICH OUT AGAIN, SO I NEED TO DOSE MEDS WEEKLY TO KEEP IT ICH FREE'... it's like most of you are so thick headed to realize that there...