I made a reflector for my old refugium light out of aluminum flashing. It dulls pretty fast, and so isn't too great at reflecting after a while. I knew that before I started, and since it was just for my fuge I didn't really care. IMO, a legitimate reflector doesn't cost very much, and probably not enough to make the hassle and reduced performace of using flashing worthwhile. I only used flashing because I was trying to convert a LOA undercabinet fixture into something I could just set on top of my refugium. They don't really make reflectors to fit LOA undercabinet fixtures so I sorta didn't have a choice but to make my own.