an eel question

jennie

Member
Hello,
I wanted to know if there was an eel that I could get that could live in my 12 gallon tank and not eat it's inhabitants.
I have
clarky clown
atlantic anemone
cleaner shrimp
arrowhead crab
choc chip star
reef crabs turbo snails
bee snails
urchen
royal gramma
gorgonian
cleaner clam
nass snails
cardinal and feather duster
This would be the last thing I would put in my tank
I may even put tha cardinals in my other tank
Thanks
 

dottiekh

Member
At one point I had a blackedge eel in a 75 gal tank. His name was Fergie and he ate approx. $300 worth of fish. At the end he was the lone inhabitant. He even went so far as to bite a shark in half. He had no intention of eating the shark, he just felt put upon when I added him. That shark lasted less than five minutes. Fergie ended up being over 3 ft. long. I now have a 125 gal tank, and I will NEVER get another eel. Having him added a whole new dimension to cleaning my tank. Eels are prone to jumping out whenever they can, and they will bite if given an opportunity. From what I hear, eel bites are not fun. The guy I purchased everything from said it was much, much worse then a dog bite, and he had to go on heavy duty antibiotics (the guy, not the eel) when he was bitten.
So, I would not recommend adding an eel to your tank, unless you are willing to let that eel be the primary occupant.
 

ruaround

Active Member
An Eel shouldnt be put into a tank that small!!! A snowflake needs atleast 55 gal, and thats pushing it. Putting an Eel in a 12 gal tank would be inhumane, please dont do it...
 

dme

Member
A snowflake needs atleast 55 gal
There are any number of eels that can be in a 55 and a SF isn`t one of them.
The blackedge moray comes in second after the yellowhead and still people need to be aware of their aggressive feeding habits for even that right now you think that your blackedge is an equal to the yellowhead, it wouldn't have a chance to hold its own in a battle with one, for that is what it means for when i said it comes in second after the yellowhead for as well, the yellowhead can take in a fish far more large then anyone might believe it could.
Both eels will bite at anything they can near too for even if they cannot swallow down the victim, they still will kill it because they are hungry. The blackedge eel grows a little larger then the yellowhead, for the yellowhead grows to 32" and the blackedge grows just under 40" at 38-39"
Eels are prone to jumping out whenever they can, and they will bite if given an opportunity. From what I hear, eel bites are not fun.
First for any eel to want to bite you, it would depend much on the moray species one has for such as your blackedge eel, it as well as the yellowhead would attempt to remove your skin if not fingers, but this idea not set right with all eels and that the majority of them will only bite if provoked or if you put your hand into their home. Not even the tess or the green moray will attack unless they were provoked into attacking for you can be right in the path they be swimming and would swim right pass you with you pissing your pants.
I had the pressure to had petted many a green morays as well as the giant moray and they are very docile creatures, but can however cause much serious damage to one they attack which is at most one would heard is their hand were bitten only in which was because they placed their hand in a rock work were they lived, but they not came out to finish off the invader of their home which means they will only battle if and when have too.
So, I would not recommend adding an eel to your tank, unless you are willing to let that eel be the primary occupant.
You are one of any n umber of people who selected either the blackedge or yellowhead morays, do not judge all eels a like to those two.
Buddy ><{{{{">
Dragon Moray Eels
 

ruaround

Active Member
Originally Posted by DME
There are any number of eels that can be in a 55 and a SF isn`t one of them.
I would have to agree with iloveeels... every site that sells snowflakes and gives minimum requirements states from 40 gal. to 55 gal. ...and like I stated "A snowflake needs atleast 55 gal, and thats pushing it."
 
J

jcrim

Guest
Originally Posted by ruaround
I would have to agree with iloveeels... every site that sells snowflakes and gives minimum requirements states from 40 gal. to 55 gal. ...and like I stated "A snowflake needs atleast 55 gal, and thats pushing it."
I also agree with this... no problem with a sfe in a 55.
Also, dotiekh, did you know when you had the blackedge that it is one of, if not the most aggressive eel. Generally should be kept in a species only tank for the very reason you discovered... they kill a lot of fish.
 

dme

Member
are you serious??? no snowflake in a 55?? simply ridiculous...all depends on the size
You can while young and still small enough, I speak of the word no for its life span. So you also disagree as well in that view?
 

merredeth

Active Member
Originally Posted by iloveels
are you serious??? no snowflake in a 55?? simply ridiculous...all depends on the size
Do you realize how big snowflake eels get? 55 gallons at a minimum is my opinion. They need room to swim around for goodness sakes!
Geeze, the guy who started this thread wanted to shove a SFE in a 12 gallon tank.
Denise M.
 

fishieness

Active Member
Originally Posted by Merredeth
Do you realize how big snowflake eels get? 55 gallons at a minimum is my opinion. They need room to swim around for goodness sakes!
Geeze, the guy who started this thread wanted to shove a SFE in a 12 gallon tank.
Denise M.

you said a 55 is minimume.... which is exactly what all of them said! so why are you preaching? and snoeflakes dont swim around too much.
and no one wanted to put on in a 12 gallon. they were wondering if there was SOME TYPE of eel that would fit in a 12 gallon. like obviously a small one.
 

merredeth

Active Member

Originally Posted by fishieness
you said a 55 is minimume.... which is exactly what all of them said! so why are you preaching? and snoeflakes dont swim around too much.
and no one wanted to put on in a 12 gallon. they were wondering if there was SOME TYPE of eel that would fit in a 12 gallon. like obviously a small one.
I stand corrected that he didn't ask specifically if he could keep a snowflake eel in the original post. However, I could have swore there was a post between 8:54 PM on 1/1/06 when DME replied and when I replied on 1/3/06 at 9:20 AM. Maybe I'm mistaken or it was deleted, I'm not sure. Accept my sincere apologies if I am incorrect. Generally, I'm not on a soapbox unless someone says something that suggests they need to do further research on other websites. I think we are all guilty of getting on soapboxes sometimes - myself included.
Snowflake eels get to be 24 inches or longer and they are nocturnal, swimming the legnth and various depths of the tank at night. They are all over the place at night
getting their excercise and seeking out food. Various websites I have researched have stated that a 55 gallon is the minimum to keep them healthy.
I have a snowflake eel and he is 20 inches long today. A few months ago when I measured him he was 18-1/2 inches long. He's growing which is part of his life cycle. It also helps that he is being fed regularly so he doesn't terrorize his tanksmates or try to eat the inverts in the tank he resides with. While he too is nocturnal for the most part, throughout the day if he wants excercise or wants to eat he does come out during the day.
When one buys any type of fish, they need to look at what the full-grown size of the fish or eel is going to be not what the size is the day they buy the creature, even if they plan on upgrading. Financial issues and emergencies happen which take priority over upgrading tanks because we want
to - that is just part of life.
I'm off my soapbox now, and never meant to get on it to begin with. I hope I have clarified my thoughts for the possible error on my part or the easily offended.
Denise M.
 

hot883

Active Member
Originally Posted by Jennie
Hello,
I wanted to know if there was an eel that I could get that could live in my 12 gallon tank and not eat it's inhabitants.
I have
clarky clown
atlantic anemone
cleaner shrimp
arrowhead crab
choc chip star
reef crabs turbo snails
bee snails
urchen
royal gramma
gorgonian
cleaner clam
nass snails
cardinal and feather duster
This would be the last thing I would put in my tank
I may even put tha cardinals in my other tank
Thanks
No, but I have seen engineer gobies that look like eels when they get bigger. Some people like them, I have 2 in my 55.
 

fishieness

Active Member
Originally Posted by hot883
No, but I have seen engineer gobies that look like eels when they get bigger. Some people like them, I have 2 in my 55.
but engineer gobies do vet very big too. much too big for a 12
and yes, i do unserstand what you are saying Merredeth
 
Top