I have researched pencil urchins and the other urchins on this site...and that's why i posted..it didn't look like any of them. It doesn't look like any pencil urchin i've ever seen. I wasn't sure if the phytoplankton would work or not, so i just tried it...someone gave it to me to try. I wondered if it worked cuz it seemed like after i added it to the tank, the urchin would come out (just a coincidence i suppose). I feed some flakes, frozen mysis and frozen brine and the occassional krill to specific fish. I'm assuming these are acceptable seeing as i've had this urchin in the tank for probably at least a year and I would say it's at least quadrulped in size since the first time I saw it.
Thanks for your help!!
(He's not out grazing right now so i can't get a clearer picture of him just yet.)