ASM G-3 vs. AquaC EV-180 vs. EuroReef

[oceanists]

Hey everybody , I hate to bring another Skimmer question buy the archives dont really answer my specific question for the most part.
So I am looking to spend around $275-$300 and I really cant go over that.
Right now I am leaning towards the ASM as I have read great things about them.
I have also heard great things about AquaC and EuroReef.... main thing with EuroReef is Im not going to be able to find the right size skimmer I need for the money I can spend, which brings the ASM G-3 into play........ however I had some questions about size, I was reading in the archives that ASM is great if you get the right size for your tank .... and I dont know what this means, so I will post my Specs
55 Gallons (standard dimentions)
A ProClear Wet/Dry (as the picture shows)
55 pounds of LR
50 Lbs of LS
1 Maroon Clown
1 Yellow Tang
1 Blue Damsel
2 Skunk Cleaner Shrimp
1 Peppermint Shrimp
Astrea Snails
Scarlet Hermits
Banded Serpant Star
Green Eye Zoos
1 Candy Cane Coral
So my question is what size ASM should I go with, I want maximum skimming without fail , but I also dont want to over do it and not get as much for going with a bigger Model.
I dont think Im going to go with the AquaC because I can get the G-3 for $248 with a Sedra 5000 Pump, and I may even go with the G-4 if I can find one at a good price.
Here is the specs for G-3
Model ASM G-3 G-Series In-Sump protein skimmer. Sedra 5000 pump INCLUDED. Rated for 250 gallons. 6-1/2-inch diameter body. 25-inch height. Requires a footprint of 11-inches x 12-inches. $248.00
Also here is the Specs for my Wet/Dry
These filters work for freshwater or saltwater tanks. This filter is rated for aquariums up to 300 gallons, and flow rates of up to 1200 GPH. Dimensions: 35"L X 12.25"W X 18"H, Capacity: 300 gallons or 1200 GPH. BIO AREA: 9 GAL. SUMP GAL: 24. Recommended Protein Skimmer: MOTORIZED 350.
Thank you in Advance as Always

Ben

 

[happyvac]

I believe ASM is actually an offshoot of the Euro-Reef brand, so they're really very similar products.
My vote is on ASM.

 

[oceanists]

Thank you , but what size for my setup?

 

[happyvac]

I think the G-3 is a good oversizing. It's rated for a 200g tank, so it should work well on a 55g. The pump is about 500gph I believe.

 

[clekchau]

as much as i like asm, they are overrated, not underrated. good skimmers though

 

[a sea k]

I don't know if this will help seeing how I have little exp. with skimmers but, when I was researching ASM skimmers I was surprised at the amount of people using the G-3 on tanks over 120 gal(most all had modded to a recirculating design that is offered from the ASM site at a modest cost)
I have a 210 gal and decided on the G-4 + model. I don't think it will fit your sump and is definately overkill. I think the G-3 should be way more than enough for your needs.
Sorry I can't give you any more concrete info.

 

[chunkysoup]

got an ASM G2 on a 55 reef... runs great

 

[acrylic51]

With that price range I would say ASM......the G3 would be an overkill, but if you can fit it in the sump go for it......There isn't anyway your going to overskim a tank........
On a side note.....ASM isn't a "offshoot" of EuroReef as alot of people want to believe.....EuroReef, ASM are knockoffs to the real European designed skimmer Deltec....
The recirc mod is a super easy DIY project.....the only thing you'll need is a holesaw bit, and another uniseal.....