Originally Posted by
Speg
Wow.. I am just totally going to have to go against everything you wrote
Firstly.. Silva will lose to Chuck guarnteed. Silva really isnt that spectacular at all. I am kinda wondering about the Chuck/Renato fight though.. I think Babalu has much more of a shot than people are thinking.
Silvia has a horrible chin. He has gotten hit really good like twice.. and both times he went down.. he didnt get ko'ed but he was rocked. Other than that people just have a wicked hard time hitting that giant. The reason that Silvia didnt flinch when he got his arm broken is just simply because he didnt feel it. He didnt hit a nerve when it broke so he didnt feel any pain. I had the same break when I was a kid and I stood up.. looked at my arm which was dangling.. and was like.. wow wtf just happend?? I didnt feel any pain in it at all.
Barnett was in UFC for a while.. and I liked seeing him fight.. but I think his last fight was to Pedro Rizzo... and you can guess how that ended up
I watch pride sometimes and I am never really impressed by many of their fighters. Like 3 guys really are dangerous and i'd love to see them fight some of the ufc top guys.
You my friend are nuts!!! Saying Silva isn't spectacular is like saying Michael Jordan was average...Babalu is one of the better submission fighters, but I think his stand up leaves a lot to be desired....If you have ever been around Tim you'd know the guy is just crazy...his arm hurt, even if it didn't hit a nerve, when he was beating it against the top of the octogon that, that would have struck something....Barnett was barred by nevada because he tested positive for roids...he was young, that was back in feb '01....keep in mind he has sins over Dan Severn, Gan McGee, Semmy Schilt, Randy Couture, Yuki Kondo, Cro cop, and Emelianenko, and finally mark Hunt.....He's only 28 , I would put him up against anyone in the UFC...here is my opinion
HW: Pride is better. UFC has a few world class HW's but prides HW roster is just deeper.
205: Pride is a little better. their roster at 205 is slightly deeper.
185: UFC by a long shot. There's no comp here. UFC takes it hands down
170: pride doesnt have a 170 weight class... so obviously this goes to the UFC
155(160): pride just because UFC dumped all there light weights and pride picked up most of the ones worth anything. but the ufc is building that division back up quickly
and we'll see BJ Penn's return against Hughes since GSP is out.