Originally Posted by PonieGirl
I stand corrected, I believe.
So, in what case would a year old tank produce nitrus acid? An excess of oxygen?
Let's first go back to basics and call it Nitrite, which is more familiar to everyone. Nitrite, preceded by Ammonia, occurs continuously in our system. Usually, the population of Nitrifying bacteria, Nitrosomonas and Nitrobacter, is at peak levels and keep Ammonia and Nitrite at levels our test kits read as zero. In actuality, if we had sensitive scientific instruments we'd detect miniscule amounts of both because in their normal life cycle our critters are constantly producing it through metabolism. Also, our pod life is constantly eating left over food particules and doing their thing. When pods die they add to it. In general, life goes on a continuous cycle. The Nitrogen "cycle" is just part of the larger "life cycle". Does that make sense? :notsure:
So, what happened in pesci's tank? Can't say for sure but, I suspect several things possible. A death, uneaten food or the most likely, the hobby test kits on the market, for the most part are very inaccurate. Some should not be purchased their so bad. The test sample is so small and the chemicals used for detection are so sensitive that a small error in any step could throw off the true reading. I, and many others, swear by Salifert brands for the best results in a hobbyist level kit. If you are willing to spend a little more money, LaMotte brand kits are the best.
Now, just a word about being corrected. Please, do not feel slighted in any way. Way back in my saltwater beginning (more than 35 years ago) the Nitrogen cycle was not clearly understood and the terminology was Greek to me. I went years not understanding it and therefore wasn't able to explain it in a clear fashion. Like you, I tried to do the best I could. Then a "new" book came out by Stephen Spotte, I don't even remember the title but, I'm sure it's around here somewhere. It explained the cycle in layman terminology and like a lightening bolt it became clear. I hope you have just had that clarity happen to you.
Best wishes and happy reefing.
Rich