The ONLY time Tap water should be used, is at the very begining (like in ur case) However, you're better of using distiled or drinking water,(from local grocery store) 5g is less than $2.00 and you'll take the safe aproach... Tap water can have many impurities/metals.phosphates,copper, ect... which is not a good idea to have in measurerable amounts in a reef or any tank where water quality is a must....
Using Tap water Once at the begining is alright, but u don't want to get into bad habits, If use it all the time u will be in for constant algeal lossing battles...the more tap u use the more inpure/out of whack your water chem will be...thus fueling the algea blooms..
Having said that: If u were in Oregon you might get away with using Tap, As one of my colegues has been using it for years. although he has a FOWL tank.. which is like comparing oranges to apples.