Carbon Question

Just wanted to know if i need to put carbon in my tank not really sure about the whole carbon thing, right now i have some in a little fillter type bag hanging in my overflow. should I just leave it or put it in and take it out every so often :notsure:
 
T

thomas712

Guest
Many feel that carbon will be good for only a couple of days then should be removed.
Others will run it 24/7 and change it every month
Still others will run it for a couple of days in a canister filter just to polish the water.
Some reading to help you decide:
http://www.aquarticles.com/articles/...%20carbon.html
Thomas
 

vyperone

Member
Interesting reading Thomas, thanks for posting the links. As a matter of fact I was at my LFS yesterday talking to him about tanks and tank qulaity and filtration. He highly recommended the carbon, telling me he changes his carbon about every 6 months, does no water changes and the pics of his tank are proof it works.... He has a 125g at home that is exclusively SPS
After reading the articles and talking to him I am going to give it a shot on my 220g....
 

chrome209

Member
but y does it elminanate doing water changes, so if i start using carbon I wont need to do water changes or do I still need to :notsure:
 

benj2112

Member
Like the use of carbon you will find lots of different views on doing water changes. My personal view is that water changes are an easy and good thing to do.
One thing about carbon that came up on a different post is that you should actually check your carbon for Phosphate. Here is a quote from steveweast about checking carbon for phosphate. He has an 850 gallon tank that is absolutly increadable.
"The one thing that everyone should do is test your carbon for phosphates!!!! Place a tablespoon of your carbon in a cup of RO water and let it sit overnight. Now test for phosphates ( as well as just RO water without the carbon in it to act as a control)...I use a Sailfert test kit. I was shocked when I did this test on the carbon that I had used for over a year... the phosphate that it was leaching was off the color chart.... so, for a year, i was just dumping phosphate into my tank.... and this, even though the label said "phosphate free"...maybe they meant that they weren't charging extra for the phosphate. I have since changed to Black Diamond which tested zero on the same test...but, I still test every new can of it ...just in case they change something."
By the way here are two links to posts that steveweast has talked about some of his views and ideas.
His ideas on Phosphate and Saltwater tanks...
https://forums.saltwaterfish.com/t/88577/500-gal-reef-converted-to-850gal-reef
Converting his 500 gallon tank to an 850 gallon reef (with lots of GREAT pictures).
https://forums.saltwaterfish.com/t/114406/phosphate-my-take-on-things
 
T

thomas712

Guest

Originally posted by Chrome209
but y does it elminanate doing water changes, so if i start using carbon I wont need to do water changes or do I still need to :notsure:

My personal take on that is NO, it will not eliminate water changes on a saltwater tank. I still do water changes and always will. I am convinced that water changes are a great thing to do for the health of the tank. Now if you used enough carbon I think they are suggesting that it could reduce the frequency of doing water changes. Sortof like running a protien skimmer reduces the frequency of doing water changes.
Thomas
 
Top