Ok but what if that was actully a prehistoric fish? That would be pretty cool. But heres some things to consider that this "Monster" could not be a "monster" and just a hoax:
1) Are there any bones in the water from when they have died?
2) People have seen 2 of these "creatures", one in new york and one in Scottland, where are the rest? Theres gotta be another one in the lake for mating....they just dont live for millions of years.
3) They say its been around since the late 1800s. It can live for more then a hundred years? COOL!