Originally Posted by fallnhorse
i have read about everything i can get my hands on, on lighting. However it just seems like a bunch of contradicting opnions to no end. Ok i use 10,000k as the bulk of my lighting soure and atincs to give it a bluing affect. To which i think means blue as penetrates further but anything over 10,000k emitts from the blue and green septrum to penetrate further. If i can understanding right? SO halides 10,000k and over are good for them? I thought even florsent t-5 where antic and less effective as halides? So i'm more confused than ever...lol. please explain about t-5 and halides over 10,000k. What the advantages for each and disadvantages.
hmmm..... im not entirely sure what you are asking, so let me try to explain and if i get something wrong then jsut point me in the right direction :thinking:
Light intensity is not measured in wats. It is measured in PAR. The K rating is the spectrum. the lower the K, the more yellow it will be. a 10000K is a white bulb, and higher than than, up to 20000K, you will have a very very very blue color. The higher the K, the less PAR there so, so although you have more blue light which is best used for photosynthesis, a lot of the light will be diffused out and not able to penetrate the water to reach your live stock. The lowerK bulbs like a 65000K, even if it is the same wattage and type of bulb, has a higher PAR output. Things will grow faster, but you will not have the nice color tha tyouw ould have with a higher K.
This is why people use actinics and high K bulbs. To give more color. and this is why they are most often used as suppliments, because they can still have the nice growth of a 10000K and have nice color like a 14000-16000K.
however, t5s also come is all the K spectrum ratings too. YOu can get them in a 10000K or even in a 65000K. But as far as it output, if you had the same amount of watts of each and at the same K, you are going to get different opinions to which is better. someone who owns MH is goign to say those are better. and anyone who owns t5s are going to say those are better. lol
Advantages of 10000K halide:
very high light output
good growth without a yellow effect
disadvantages:
only covers about a 2 foot square of light
can get very hot
pricey
Advantages of 10000K t5:
very slim to fit many over your tank
very high light output
good growth without a yellow effect
fit all the way across your tank, so you can cover your entire tank (i have this problem because i have 1 150 watt over my 36" tank)
very cool in temp (and in looks. haha)
you can get a good number in a variety or watts anywhere form 1-8 bulbs
disadvantages:
pricey