confused. # of fish verse inch per gal

dave vg

New Member
What is the golden rule. I have heard it depends on messyness verse active verse swimming room filtration etc. I would rather go with more and small than big and none. I have a 90 gal with 90 + lbs of live rock, empior 400 and a cc 125 skimmer. I have posted a list here but someone said to many fish. Now i'm confused about the rule.
Dave
 

drose

Member
I've heard 1 per 5 gallons as a loose rule. Many factors play into this. Here's an excerpt from Ophiuria that explains it:
There is no set number because it depends on many many variables...the type of fish, the "footprint" of the tank (eg, a standard 120g is a 4' tank - not great for tangs - but a 125 is typically longer and suitable). It depends on the temperment of the fish - are they aggressive and territorial? Some of the smallest fish have the biggest attitudes. Are they "big eaters" like some aggressive fish, producing a lot of waste? And do you have things like corals...coral tanks, regardless of whether you keep hard or soft corals, tend to have a significantly lower bioload and number of fish than the tank can in theory hold.
So, the answer is that there is no set answer or guideline. What is important is researching the fish, their behavior and adult size of the fish. Stocking slowly, feeding a reasonable amount, and staying up on water parameters and water changes will help. Your overall stocking will come down to water parameters, behavior and personal appeal of stock size.
As for other animals, in theory, yes, anything that consumes food produces waste and has an impact on your bioload. How much that actually impacts things overall is relatively less than fish. Corals are often fed, impacting water quality significantly.
 

dave vg

New Member
So most tanks are over stocked by that measure. I selected my fish by successful tanks i have seen in posts here and a few other fourms on the net. There are people who keep more inches per gal in the same size tank than i plan to. not that this makes it right. several people stock by bio load. if they start to see thing's going up they reduice there #'s. Of course i would like the best enviroment for my future fish thats important to me.
This is the stocking order and list i posted in another thread:
1) 3 or 4 Banggai Cardinalfish
2) 2 Tank Raised Ocellaris Clownfish
4) Fiji Foxface
3) Blue Hippo Tang
4) 1 Coral Beauty Angel, 1 Flame Angel added at the same
 

bang guy

Moderator
Also keep in mind that overstocked tanks require more experience to maintain health. That one reason why new hobbiests really should stock light.
From your list:
Only 2 Banggai. If you add 4 you will have to remove 2 or the dominant pair will remove them for you once they mature. I don't have a problem with adding 4 unti lthere's a pair and then returning the other two.
The Hippo should be in a larger tank, at least 6' but 8' is much better.
 

beatlesfan

Member
if i could add somthing to bang guy's post i would nto put both angelfish in the tank NO MATTER WHAT. of course i have no water in my tank yet so i am not an exper it is simply what i have learned. But if you want to be sure then wait for a better person to answer you.
 

dave vg

New Member
Originally Posted by Bang Guy
Also keep in mind that overstocked tanks require more experience to maintain health. That one reason why new hobbiests really should stock light.
From your list:
Only 2 Banggai. If you add 4 you will have to remove 2 or the dominant pair will remove them for you once they mature. I don't have a problem with adding 4 unti lthere's a pair and then returning the other two.
The Hippo should be in a larger tank, at least 6' but 8' is much better.
Point taken thanks. I will get some seat time and re-think things before i think about stocking on the edge. The hippo is out. What about the others. I have a Coral Beauty now in a 30 gal. now. Was going to add it and a flame at the same time.
Dave
 
Top