I posted a thread asking the same question not to long ago. The consensus was that you could keep a squamosa clam under VHO, and that would be the only species. All others pretty much require MH. For clams to be perfectly happy, MH is a must. Just remember that success is in terms of years not months, and some may say they have kept clams under VHO, but it has probably only been for a few months. HTH. (hopefully some more experienced people will comment as well :joy: )