I know nothing about the skimmer you are asking about, however i will give you my two cents worth on what i like and dislike. I have used a couple different skimmers now, and I do not like the SeaClone skimmers. Hard to control and do not seem to work well. I totally dig my Tunze skimmer. They are a little more expensive than most, but everything i read about them supports thir price. Also, first hand experience is excellent. Anyway, you may not have wanted these comments, but now you have them! Good luck!