That's very true, and a good point. However, I do feel that since they allowed a classified section and it was such a big part of the site, they probably should have kept it. Also, most people that are going to buy from this site will buy from this site anyway. If they wanted to buy/trade with other reeefers, they will find another way to do so (C-list, another site, the bay, etc.).
I definitely get what you're saying, but I think it hurt their traffic more than it helped their business.
An example of what I mean is the artist J.Cole. When his album leaked, he said that he didn't care because the people who were going to buy his album, will still buy his album. The people who weren't, won't. The free bootleg downloads are always there, but the supporters will still support (I did). Weird example, I know, but I think it clarifies my point.
SWF had a lot of traffic and I'm sure they lost at least a little bit from getting rid of the Buy/Sell. I doubt they gained much business because people who wanted used merchandise will find it elsewhere. People who wanted to buy from SWF will still buy from them. Only difference is now there's less people on the site.
now I'm contemplating going joining another site, partially because I will be looking for a Buy/Sell section so I can buy frags for my new tank. If I do, and I like it better, there's a good chance SWF won't be my Go-To site in the event that I do need a bulk order.
That's just how I see it.
In all honesty, they saw a drop in sales I believe. Also, the good majority of us here on the forum, don't buy much anymore. If anything at all.